5 ms·
> . We face a choice between a feature our users want and the degree to which that feature can be built to embody user control and privacy. It can't be said fo
by shmerl 13y ago
> . We face a choice between a feature our users want and the degree to which that feature can be built to embody user control and privacy.
It can't be said for all users. I don't want it. No DRM junk in the browser please. I understand that she probably means some estimated majority, which is unfortunate (i.e. majority accepting unethical practice like DRM).
> Firefox users would need to use another browser every time they want to watch a controlled video
Irrelevant for many users of DRM-free OSes (like Linux) who won't have any DRM backend for EME anyway. I.e. it really sounds like "users would need another OS".
> Each person will be able to decide whether to activate the DRM implementation or to leave it off and not watch DRM-controlled content.
I hope there will be a switch for disabling the whole EME altogether. Even better, I'd prefer builds of Firefox free of any DRM sickness. It's very unfortunate that this garbage is finding its way into the open source browser which always stood for the users' rights more than many others.
- rayiner 13y ago> majority accepting unethical practice like DRM Are you kidding? DRM is great. I love being able to just pay money to Netflix in return for content. DRM enables that nice, clear-cut transaction. What's the alternative? Judging by the rest of the web, it involves tracking your internet activity and throwing advertising in your face.
- shmerl 13y agoDRM is never great. Show me one user who actually appreciates DRM itself. What you meant above is that users like the service. They could like it even more if it hadn't DRM garbage attached to it. I.e. DRM has nothing to do with what users like - it always degrades the quality of the service and the digital goods it delivers.
- rayiner 13y agoThat's like saying nobody likes the turnstile on the subway. Of course not, but it enables the service to exist in the form it does. I'd much rather go through the turnstile, as awkward as it can be if you've got a suitcase, etc, than be forced to watch advertisements during my subway ride...
- shmerl 13y agoNo, DRM does not enable the service because it's not an essential part of it. The service could work without DRM all the same while being ethical and more user friendly at the same time. DRM is like a sickness attached to an otherwise healthy product. It only becomes better when you remove it.
- rayiner 13y agoThat's like saying the subway turnstile isn't an essential part of the subway. It's only true if you define "essential" in a narrow technical way that ignores the realities of having to monetize the use of products and services.
- shmerl 13y ago> realities of having to monetize the use of products and services. Essential means technically and financially essential. I.e. without it the service can't work or can't bring profit. DRM is neither of that. Those who require DRM [publishers] have no technical or financial reasons to justify it. No valid ones at least (all reasons they usually voice are false, and their true reasons they usually don't voice).
- rayiner 13y agoThat makes no sense. What "true reasons" do publishers have for DRM that aren't fundamentally financial?
- shmerl 13y agoI can think of several: 1. Monopolistic lock-in. DRM is more than often used to control the market. It happened with Apple in the past, and was one of the key reasons that music publishers realized that being DRM-free is actually better for them. This reason also includes DRM derivatives like DMCA-1201 and the like. It's all about control (over the markets, over users and etc.). 2. Covering one's incompetence. DRM is used to justify failing sales (i.e. when execs are questioned about why the product performs poorly, they say "Pirates! But worry not - we put more DRM in place"). 3. Ignorance and / or stupidity (many execs have no clue and might believe that DRM actually provides some benefit). This type can be called DRM Lysenkoism. None of these reasons are valid, all of them are crooked and anti-user, but they are often present in various combinations.
- quasque 13y agoIf you're watching streamed video, the DRM is completely transparent. I don't see how that is a degradation in service. The only way it would be an issue is if you're trying to rip the stream. But if you've paid the provider for streaming only, rather than to download and keep a copy, then that's also not really degrading the quality of service. Similarly, the prohibition on bringing a video camera in to record cinema screenings does not reduce the quality of the cinema experience. In general, I don't really see a problem with DRM that is temporally bound to the moment of consumption.
- shmerl 13y ago> If you're watching streamed video, the DRM is completely transparent. I don't see how that is a degradation in service. It is crippling usability in several ways: 1. DRM is usually not portable (or not ported at least). I.e. most probably it's tied to certain devices / operating systems / applications and etc. For the end user it translates to "you can't watch it on the device / operating system / application of your choice". 2. DRM prevents backups. If the service goes bust or you lose connectivity - you have no access to your data. 3. DRM poses a security / privacy threat. Being transparent doesn't make it any better - it only makes it worse (think of a hidden camera). All those are clearly examples of degraded usability no matter how "transparent" some DRM is.
- quasque 13y agoRegarding your first point, hasn't this always been the case even before DRM? For example, one cannot directly interpret the magnetic fluctuations encoded onto a cassette tape - a tape player is needed to transduce the signal. DRM just takes this a step further by introducing cryptography and obfuscation into the decoding process. I don't think backups are relevant to DRM-laden streaming video, given that it's someone else's data that you happen to be observing. I'm not sure what you mean by a security and privacy threat. Surely it is no more of a threat than visiting potentially untrusted websites, or using closed-source or unverified open-source binaries, in the first place?
- shmerl 13y ago
- sp332 13y agoMovie rentals existed before Netflix. It's always been technically possible to make illegal copies of movies. But most people would rather have a legal option. Otherwise everyone would skip Netflix and just use the Pirate Bay. Edit: To be clear, I'm saying that people will pay for a legal streaming service even if they could rip it off for free.
- aqme28 13y agoAnd just like movie rentals, it's still possible to rip off DRM'd content. It isn't hard to screen-record, and it never will be. As long as that exists, what's the point of DRM anyway?
- wolfgke 13y agoIllegal copy from Pirate Bay: free (as beer) and no DRM. Legal copy: you have to pay and endure DRM. Now let the market decide.
- sp332 13y agoThe market has already decided on "both". The people who spend the most money on music are the same people to pirate the most music.
- wolfgke 13y agoCorrect. Thus it is a very bad idea to infuriate the people who love music/movies with DRM mechanisms, because otherwise they'll just pirate and not buy.
- tomp 13y agoI also love being able to pay Apple money in exchange for DRM-free music. Also, DRM on video is approximately 0-efficient; pirates will still rip movies and upload them to torrent sites, freeloaders will still find free low-quality streaming movie sites, and the majority of non-technical users wouldn't be able to rip streaming video even without DRM. So: NO.
- rayiner 13y ago> the majority of non-technical users wouldn't be able to rip streaming video even without DRM. How hard would it be to make an app that made this easy for non-technical users, without DRM?
- tomp 13y agoAs easily as Mozilla can make an open-source DRM client... simple (DRM will be broken sooner rather than later, if it hasn't been already), but you can't distribute it. So we're back to "pirate channels", like all the movies today. And in any case, this misses the point: non-technical users won't distribute pirated content, even if they could rip it. Who are they going to distribute it to? Friends? Whoever wants free movies, can get them easily. But the main advantage of streaming, on-demand-ness, remains in the hands of the big players, who can afford to lease the servers and pay for the bandwidth.
- chimeracoder 13y agoHow hard was it to make Popcorn Time? I don't know, but however long, it apparently wasn't prohibitive. And I don't think it'd be tough to clone.
- josephlord 13y agoWhat about Netflix requires DRM? I know that the studios currently require it but what benefit does it actually serve? How much of the content on Netflix is not available to pirate if so inclined?
- shmerl 13y agoIt all is about obliging the insanity of movie publishers. And why they require it? No valid reason.