4 ms·
I didn't make that point at all. I really have no clue whether the degree has an impact on job performance. All I meant to say is that many teachers are require
by sanderjd 13y ago
I didn't make that point at all. I really have no clue whether the degree has an impact on job performance. All I meant to say is that many teachers are required to get it to progress in their careers and that it is expensive to do so without much future compensation for that expense relative to other degrees.
- tptacek 13y agoWhere are teachers required to have that masters?
- sanderjd 13y agoYeah, I figured I'd be (rightly) called out on that - I don't know of anywhere that teachers are required to get the degree, but I know teachers (in Colorado) whose career progressions are limited early on without it (hence "required ... to progress in their careers").
- tptacek 13y agoDo we know if the median teacher also has a masters? I know what my kids teachers make (significantly more), so wouldn't be surprised to learn that 70k is reachable without the degree. 70k is significantly above the US median salary. FWIW: My mom was (until a couple years ago) a CPS teacher with a Masters and a focus on BD/LD teaching; she has strong feelings about this stuff, but I think I might disagree with a lot of them.
- sanderjd 13y agoTo change tack a bit, because I don't have data to answer your question: Am I meant to think that 70k is a really high median salary for the teaching profession? Because I really don't - it seems really low for such an important profession. Especially now that so much teaching at the college level is done by similarly low-paid adjuncts, I wonder, why does it seem like our society doesn't think teaching should be an attractive employment choice for the smart, talented, and well-educated among us?
- tptacek 13y agoWell, ~70k is ~20k higher than the median salary; in other words, an entire full-time minimum wage salary higher. That 70k salary comes with a 3-month break and (much more importantly) a defined-benefit pension plan. Relative to investment bankers, teachers are not highly paid. But relative to the economy and, in particular, to supply/demand, they have what seems to be a pretty solid deal.
- sanderjd 13y agoI don't think either minimum wage workers or investment bankers are the proper comparison. I think we should be talking about professionals like doctors, lawyers, engineers, and other businesspeople; those are the professions that teaching competes (largely unsuccessfully) with for talent.
- tptacek 13y agoOk, let's make that comparison: a CPS teacher makes 70k, and teachers have low single-digit unemployment and defined-benefit pensions. Lawyers, on the other hand, make a median 110k, but don't have a 3 month vacation, don't as a rule have defined-benefit pensions, and have ~12%(!) unemployment. A lawyer is also required to shoulder an average of 85k of postgraduate education to enter the field; a high school teacher can start with a bachelors. Unemployment rates for teachers are projected to fall. The unemployment picture for lawyers is bleak, due to the slow-motion collapse of biglaw.
- sanderjd 13y agoAnd yet, those current and prospective unemployed lawyers almost certainly aren't flocking to become teachers! There are absolutely things that are attractive about teaching, I'm not at all arguing that it's the pits, just that it isn't as competitive for talent as I would like it to be. I'd love to see more of those smart kids from Stanford that go work on websites go educate our youth instead.
- danielweber 13y agoI read "most earners of masters degrees can expect to enter fields with significantly higher salaries, especially later in their careers" as "people with masters degrees make a lot of money, so we should people with a masters of education to also have high earning potential." (That may not be what you said; I'm just saying how I read it to clarify discussion.) I should not have implied that you said it indicated job performance; that was the wrong place for me to challenge your statement (as I read it). Instead, I will say that it's not proper to treat a masters in education as giving the same signal as a masters in other fields.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]