4 ms·
Here's an article from 1981 lamenting that although the science was settled and everyone agreed that lectures weren't any more effective than unstructured read
by ZeroGravitas 13y ago
Here's an article from 1981 lamenting that although the science was settled and everyone agreed that lectures weren't any more effective than unstructured reading, you couldn't get the people giving lectures to stop doing so, generally for rather insipid reasons:
https://www.brookes.ac.uk/services/ocsld/resources/20reasons.html https://www.brookes.ac.uk/services/ocsld/resources/20reasons...
"Disclaimer:
The ideas, explanations and evidence which form the arguments of this paper are not the outcome of years of esoteric study and hence accessible only to professional educationalists. On the contrary, they are readily available in popular paperbacks, notably in Donald Bligh's "What's the Use of Lectures?" The evidence is not new. The arguments have been made before. Only the continued prevalence of lecturing justifies the writing of this paper."
[...]
"Conclusion: I would not like to leave the impression that I feel that there is no justification for ever lecturing. I lecture myself (though seldom for more than fifteen minutes at a stretch and then seldom when written substitutes are available). I believe there are circumstances when a well structured, well paced, varied, lively lecture can be the most efficient teaching method. But I do believe there is far more lecturing going on than can reasonably be justified by the evidence concerning the efficiency of lectures, especially bearing in mind the nature of the educational goals we claim to be striving for. I believe this state of affairs to be largely due to ignorance, attitudes, and institutional constraints, rather than to any inherent virtues of lecturing which I have overlooked, and which everyone else is privy to. I believe both institutions and validating bodies ought to be asking serious questions about courses which appear to be based primarily on lecturing as the dominant teaching method."