3 ms·
A Masters in Education is, literally, an "advanced degree" by every definition I've ever seen. Ignoring definitions, the point is that it's expensive in both di
by sanderjd 13y ago
A Masters in Education is, literally, an "advanced degree" by every definition I've ever seen. Ignoring definitions, the point is that it's expensive in both direct and opportunity costs relative to its future earning potential - most earners of masters degrees can expect to enter fields with significantly higher salaries, especially later in their careers.
- TheMagicHorsey 13y agoAnother point of irrationality. Nobody can show any correlation between having that masters degree, and being a better teacher. Its just more institutions included into the education industrial complex ... now the Masters accreditation institutions fight reform too ... because without this shit system, we don't need them and their deadweight either.
- sanderjd 13y agoThis is weird, you and danielweber both put the same words in my mouth. I made no comment at all about the value of the degree, only about its necessity to teachers and its expense.
- TheMagicHorsey 13y agoI can't speak for the other person, but my point was only that the expense of the degree wasn't actually necessary for the proper functioning of an education system. Its just more waste.
- danielweber 13y agoI agree with your first part that a Masters in Education is a hassle to get, even if you are currently a teacher during the day plugging away at night school to get the degree. It's a lot of sunk time (and money if you don't have it paid for somehow). I'll disagree that it's any benefit to job performance. Any evidence that it is indicative of other job qualifications is very limited. It's telling that the first page of google results for "benefits of a masters degree in education" are mostly about how it can improve the teacher's salary, not how it makes one a better teacher. Master's degrees for other liberal arts degrees don't bring any salary boost.
- sanderjd 13y agoI didn't make that point at all. I really have no clue whether the degree has an impact on job performance. All I meant to say is that many teachers are required to get it to progress in their careers and that it is expensive to do so without much future compensation for that expense relative to other degrees.
- tptacek 13y agoWhere are teachers required to have that masters?
- sanderjd 13y agoYeah, I figured I'd be (rightly) called out on that - I don't know of anywhere that teachers are required to get the degree, but I know teachers (in Colorado) whose career progressions are limited early on without it (hence "required ... to progress in their careers").
- tptacek 13y agoDo we know if the median teacher also has a masters? I know what my kids teachers make (significantly more), so wouldn't be surprised to learn that 70k is reachable without the degree. 70k is significantly above the US median salary. FWIW: My mom was (until a couple years ago) a CPS teacher with a Masters and a focus on BD/LD teaching; she has strong feelings about this stuff, but I think I might disagree with a lot of them.
- sanderjd 13y agoTo change tack a bit, because I don't have data to answer your question: Am I meant to think that 70k is a really high median salary for the teaching profession? Because I really don't - it seems really low for such an important profession. Especially now that so much teaching at the college level is done by similarly low-paid adjuncts, I wonder, why does it seem like our society doesn't think teaching should be an attractive employment choice for the smart, talented, and well-educated among us?