3 ms·
I don't mean to be that jerk, but I'm going to anyway: citations are needed on this: "Statistical studies have long shown that..." "We"—schools, society, etc.—
by jseliger 13y ago
I don't mean to be that jerk, but I'm going to anyway: citations are needed on this: "Statistical studies have long shown that..."
"We"—schools, society, etc.—can't really control parenting. But we can control schools, and per the articles I list here: http://jseliger.wordpress.com/2009/11/12/susan-engel-doesnt-get-2/ http://jseliger.wordpress.com/2009/11/12/susan-engel-doesnt-... , it is probably possible to get substantially better outcomes than the ones we're getting now, chiefly through better teachers. At the moment, most public school teachers are paid in lockstep based on seniority—CS teachers and PE teachers get the same pay—and can't be fired after their second or third year of teaching, and that creates a lot of perverse incentives.
- gfodor 13y ago""We"—schools, society, etc.—can't really control parenting." Sounds like you need a citation of your own. I'm sure you could come up with hundreds of ways to apply money towards the solution of improving parenting.
- jseliger 13y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7739746 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7739746 .
- cjensen 13y agoSee aaronharnly's comment for a book full of cites https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7739206 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7739206
- jseliger 13y agoHanushek is an advocate for some kind of charter reform, per his Econtalk talk: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2008/07/hanushek_on_edu_2.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2008/07/hanushek_on_edu_2.h... . I think he would loosely agree with my above points.
- ceras 13y ago> "We"—schools, society, etc.—can't really control parenting. Programs exist for this with some positive results. Here's one from a quick Google search: http://evidencebasedprograms.org/1366-2/nurse-family-partnership http://evidencebasedprograms.org/1366-2/nurse-family-partner...
- jseliger 13y agoThere are innumerable small-scale programs that show limited positive results, but almost none of them scale up (see http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2007/11/scale-matters/2243/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2007/11/scale-ma... for more on that general problem; her book The Upside of Down is also good on this subject). Lots of small-scale Head Start programs show promise too, but the program's effects on the whole fade out after a couple years, and on a large scale it hasn't done anything except provide daycare and jobs. Programs like "Nurse-Family Partnership – Top Tier" already operate. I know because I've written numerous Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) Healthy Start Initiative (HSI) proposals (see more about the program here: http://blog.seliger.com/2013/12/15/hrsas-healthy-start-initiative-inadvertently-illuminates-how-grant-funding-decisions-are-actually-made/ http://blog.seliger.com/2013/12/15/hrsas-healthy-start-initi...) that attempt to do just this. I do grant writing for nonprofit and public agencies, so I see citations like yours all the time. Next time I write an HSI or similar program, I'll cite "Nurse-Family Partnership – Top Tier." Doing so isn't going to make the program any better, because HSI has been operating for a couple decades, under different names, and hasn't accomplished much on a large scale, in part because of the scale-up problems described in the first paragraph. Ideas like "Nurse-Family Partnership – Top Tier" sound good, but the gap between the real world and the proposal world is quite wide (http://blog.seliger.com/2010/04/11/the-real-world-and-the-proposal-world/ http://blog.seliger.com/2010/04/11/the-real-world-and-the-pr...). Zuckerberg has evidently learned this. Apologies for the length of this post, but the issue is a complex one that is hard to explain and harder to understand—hence all the links!
- ceras 13y agoMany thanks for the info - this is a topic I care about deeply so I appreciate your time and the resources you mentioned. I understand that scaling is very difficult. But what makes you think scaling these types of programs is harder than scaling those that directly target education? In fact, the first link you provide talks about the difficulty of scaling an educational program. I'd love for there to be strong evidence backing a scalable program that addresses generational poverty, be it an educational approach or not, but I don't know of any. Until we find that, I really don't think it's helpful to limit public discourse to only one potential solution to such a complex problem.
- danielweber 13y ago"We"—schools, society, etc.—can't really control parenting. But we can control schools, I agree with this statement as it is. But I think it's one of the problems. There have been complaints elsewhere in this thread about the strict work rules under which teachers operate. And I agree with them. You know the story of the drunk looking for his keys under the streetlight instead of in the bushes where he lost them, saying "the light's better here"? If we keep on expecting schools to be the magical institution that fixes society's problems, we are going to keep on being disappointed, all the while greatly bothering all the people working at the school in the meantime.