3 ms·
You've switched topics. I pointed out that the article was bad journalism. Now you want to discuss the underlying statistics used to generate a report like that
by dalke 13y ago
You've switched topics. I pointed out that the article was bad journalism. Now you want to discuss the underlying statistics used to generate a report like that.
Based on the page you pointed to, it's hard to draw any specific conclusions. It suggests that the increase in crime is because of the change in Swedish policy since 1975 towards more diversity.
However, it could be because Sweden changed policies to report more crimes, or people have decided to report more crimes. As a well-known example, the number of reported rapes in Sweden is very high. BRÅ attributes it to using a different reporting scheme and a broader definition of rape than the other countries. Eg, (and if I understand the details correctly) if a woman says that she's been raped by her husband every other night for the last year, then the Swedish policy is to report that as 180 reports of rapes, while other countries might regard it as a single report, or something that's not reportable at all.
Or for another observation about policy changes, since the 1970s there has also been an increasing move towards privatization of the Swedish economy, and an increase in the Gini coefficient. With the statistics presented, it's equally possible to argue that the movement away from traditional social democracy has contributed to increased levels of crime.
Or for still another observation, the number of crimes has gone up while the number of Saabs sold has gone down. Perhaps it's all those drivers with old Saabs committing crimes in order to get spare parts for their beloved vehicles. That's extremely unlikely, but that the type of conclusions one gets when only looking for statistical correlations.
These complexities in statical analysis are very well-known. Any analysis which doesn't even bring up the issues in the introductory article must be treated with deep suspicion. An article like this one, which appears to have cherry-picked 15 year old report without giving the context to understand it, is almost certainly not a trustworthy source of information.