4 ms·
The place I work for deals with about 20 different site's oauth processes and it's amazing how widely varied they are. Some of them let you restrict the redirec
by stormbrew 13y ago
The place I work for deals with about 20 different site's oauth processes and it's amazing how widely varied they are. Some of them let you restrict the redirect_uri while others don't, some of them still need you to send a login/password pair for the first request rather than do an oauth flow, but then still use oauth-style tokens all over the place. A couple of them require that the token be passed as a query string parameter instead of as a header for all requests. Being responsibly secure with all of them is quite difficult. It doesn't help that it's very difficult to have a development environment work properly with them, so doing active work against them is often painful.
OAuth is basically a complete mess, implementation-wise, and that's really sad since it's such a promising and useful premise.
- MAGZine 13y agoThat's really unfortunate. I read through the RFC, and IIRC it is pretty consistent on those details. Can't stop people from badly implementing a spec :(
- fnom 12y agoi've heard great stuff about oauth.io . they try to provide an abstractionlayer that handles the various different implementations (often buggy or not to spec) of oauth.