3 ms·
The loophole in the 5th amendment to the U.S. Constitution is worse than that. It is wide enough to fly an entire fleet of drones through, in formation. First
by logfromblammo 13y ago
The loophole in the 5th amendment to the U.S. Constitution is worse than that. It is wide enough to fly an entire fleet of drones through, in formation.
Firstly, there is no mention of citizenship. Secondly, the loophole covers any land force, sea force, or militia, and the service can be in any time of war (not necessarily currently engaged in battle) or any time of public danger. There is no mention of loyalty to the U.S. as enemy or ally.
Obviously, the intent of the loophole was to address the question "How can we possibly fight a war if 23 people have to hear evidence before every musket ball flies?" But thanks to poor bounds checking, the protection against arbitrary extrajudicial executions is severely weakened.
By a malicious reading of the amendment, I could argue that, by the tenets of Islam, every Muslim is a member of the militia, and that every member is called upon to wage war upon the unfaithful, heretics, and apostates. That is, they would all be "Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger." They don't even need to be at war against the U.S. The loophole does not specify.
It would seem that the source code for U.S. Government should be updated, and a patch released.
- baldeagle 13y agoYeah, but the minimum 34 maintainers (2/3s of the states) have been arguing about the colour of the bike shed since the time of mainstream horse drawn carriages. Little known fact: the most recent pull request accepted into the Repo was submitted in Sept 1789. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twenty-seventh_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twenty-seventh_Amendment_to_the...
- dalke 13y agoUnless you can find something which revokes a statement in the Treaty of Tripoli - and given 200+ years it might well have changed - you can't apply your malicious reading because the US has said it does not have hatred or ill-will regarding the tenets of Islam. Specifically, the US Senate unanimously wrote that the US "has in itself no character of enmity against the laws, religion, or tranquility, of Mussulmen" (that being the older term for Muslims). That nitpick aside, your statement is still true - the loophole would be to declare that, say, the tenants of the Wahhabi branch, or the Ahmadiyya branch, of Islam are not part of the true Muslim faith as meant in the Treaty of Tripoli.
- logfromblammo 13y agoThere is no requirement that the U.S. be a party to the war, or that the targeted individual be enemy or ally. All that is required is that they be a potential combatant in any war or emergency. The U.S. could target a South Korean soldier at a defense conference in the U.S. South Korea is still at war with North Korea, so that's a soldier, on the job, during a war. All the requirements are met. It does not matter one little bit whether the soldier is actually a danger to the U.S. or anyone associated with the U.S. It might cause a diplomatic ruckus, but the U.S. is allowed to do it by the 5th amendment. It's a horrible, horrible loophole.
- dalke 13y agoOh, I agree. It just that you can't use the specific example you gave of saying that a follower of the Muslim faith is an enemy.
- logfromblammo 13y agoI gave no such example. The person targeted under the loophole does not have to be an enemy. The requirement is that they be in military or militia service during a war or public crisis. Any war. Any crisis. If you are shooting Martian invaders with a slingshot, you fall into the loophole. If you are an Indonesian soldier delivering drinking water to tsunami victims in Indonesia, you fall into the loophole. Get it?
- dalke 13y agoI understand your distinction, and I stand corrected in my use of the term "enemy" when it doesn't apply, but my point still stands. There is a minor sliver of an exception to your loophole, because the US has declared that some things are not of themselves causes for "enmity", one of which is adherence to the Muslim faith. If you say that being in the militia is a requirement of Islam (and a quick search of a Koran does not find that to be true), then it was equally true when the US signed that statement; and I have no doubt that some Muslim somewhere was involved in a public crisis even at the time it was being signed in the Senate. But change one single iota of your premise away from specific treaty terms, or clarify that the US has the ability to declare someone to not actually be a Muslim, then you're golden. You also need to be careful to not trounce over other treaties, like the UN Charter. That's not hard, if the last 50 years of US military interventions is any indication, but it's not so easy as only using the language of the loophole.