2 ms·
It seems to me that the article ultimately addresses a straw man... I don't see anyone saying "Scientists would be better off if they adopted best practices tha
by jerf 13y ago
It seems to me that the article ultimately addresses a straw man... I don't see anyone saying "Scientists would be better off if they adopted best practices that a first-year student would think are a good idea without any understanding" or "Scientists would be better off if they got terrible software engineers to help them". Most, if not all, of what's in the article is bad software engineering.
In fact, we are well aware that bad programming is not confined to scientists, and at the risk of being tautological, better programming practices lead to better programming outcomes than worse ones, regardless of science or not. (And note my careful confinement to "programming outcomes"... I won't promise that better programming practices lead to better final outcomes unconditionally, though I'd be willing to state there are times and places where it is called for.)
There are a lot of cargo-culting "software engineers" who blindly apply principles in stupid manners, but that's hardly what people are calling for here.