6 ms·
> Thank goodness for a little government regulation and that created competition. Heh. Funny comment, since it's the government who created in the first place
by ekianjo 13y ago
> Thank goodness for a little government regulation and that created competition.
Heh. Funny comment, since it's the government who created in the first place the band of 3/4 major actors in very country, by restricting the entrance with a system of auctions to get access to mobile frequencies.
That's precisely because we lack competition that the prices are not coming down, and that's what the government has been preventing for ages in the mobile industry. With 3/4 key actors it's very easy to have everyone meet for dinner and agree on fixed prices that are not going to move.
- adanto6840 13y agoMaybe I'm naive, but how else would you prevent interference -- or even a nefarious "competitor" from otherwise "using" the frequencies? I know very little about radio waves/signals, but AFAIK a HTTP-type approach wouldn't work without a lot of up-front collaboration and a free market wouldn't have went that direction either, correct?
- logicchains 13y agoHere's a libertarian argument against government ownership of the airwaves: http://mises.org/journals/jls/20_2/20_2_2.pdf http://mises.org/journals/jls/20_2/20_2_2.pdf. Essentially the idea is that the frequencies would be treated as private property, with the exact nature of this being worked out in the courts. There's precedent for this from 1926, before the US government officially took up ownership of the airwaves, in Tribune Co. v. Oak Leaves Broadcasting Station. "The Chicago Daily Tribune, calling itself WGN... broadcast entertainment as a means of marketing its publication. WGN filed a complaint in state court against another radio station, Oak Leaves, which had begun broadcasting in an adjacent wavelength. WGN claimed that it was necessary to maintain at least a 50-kilocycle separation between stations located within 100 miles of each other. They accused the Oak Leaves station of injuring their lawfully acquired business property. Chancellor Francis S. Wilson decided the case in the tradition of property rights to common resources. His landmark decision, which established homesteading rights in “the ether,” found precedent in western water rights, among other established property traditions. Wilson concluded the court was "compelled to recognize rights which have been acquired by reason of the outlay and expenditure of money and the investment of time. . . . We are of the further opinion that, under the circumstances in this case, priority of time creates a superiority in right." The Congress responded to Oak Leaves instantly. After years of debate and delay on a radio law, both houses jumped to pass a December 1926 resolution stating that no private rights to ether would be recognized as valid, mandating that broadcasters immediately sign waivers relinquishing all rights, and disclaiming any vested interests." *Edit: This ownership wouldn't necessarily extend to _entire spectrums_ as it does in the case of the government selling spectrum. In Tribune Co. v. Oak Leaves Broadcasting Station, for instance, WGN was granted the right to broadcast on a specific frequency within a certain area, which differs immensely from a company being able to 'buy' a series of frequencies from the government such that no other entity in the country may uses this spectrum.
- Retric 13y agoThe government has sold the cellphone bands to private companies making your point moot.
- logicchains 13y agoFirstly, it's not 'my point'; I was presenting that argument as an answer to the parent post's question of how else interference could be prevented. Secondly, the ownership of entire cellphone bands isn't the only kind of property right over spectrum that could exist. Ownership of entire cellphone bands would actually be somewhat unlikely. For a court following 'Tribune Co. v. Oak Leaves Broadcasting Station' to consider an entire spectrum across the entire nation as property in court, the transmitting organisation would have to show that it was and had been using that entire spectrum to transmit content across every part of the nation. Such a situation would be unlikely, as the organisation would likely have faced competition for spectrum use before it could expand its own spectrum use over the entire country.
- Retric 13y agoFirst off, by bringing up / presenting "a libertarian argument against government ownership of the airwaves" it becomes your point even if you don't agree with it. Also, so saying their not owned by the government does make your point moot. At a more basic level, before technology improved the high frequency bands where directly worthless but that would not have stopped people squatting them just like with DNS. Secondly, unlike radio cellphones need to broadcast so you need a setup that does not break down as people move around the country thus at least the protocol needs to be national for a given frequency.* Simply giving a free for all to the first people to use a given spectrum is horribly inefficient and effectively just a first come first served auction. *Radio and TV are examples of this where the protocol does not change even if different people are using the same frequency in different areas, but if it's unregulated they could in theory do whatever they want.
- logicchains 13y ago
- danem 13y agoThe economist Ronald Coase wrote a very interesting (and brief) history on the FCC, and makes a compelling argument for the use of auctions to grant rights to spectrums. While long, I think the article is well worth reading. http://thesefragments.files.wordpress.com/2007/07/coase_fcc.pdf http://thesefragments.files.wordpress.com/2007/07/coase_fcc....
- ekianjo 13y agoOne way would be to have the infrastructure financed by both the government and the actors, and all actors using the same infrastructure, and therefore competing on prices and services instead of each of them having a separate monopoly on their band. That's exactly how it works for phone lines, and that's where competition worked the best to bring the prices down.
- newman314 13y agoA) the government should have picked GSM or CDMA and mandated that. B) they should have then enacted regulation to permit roaming for "reasonable" access fees. This would have the net effect of not forcing 4 companies to build essentially the same network across the US. Showing to Europe is an eye opening experience. Land somewhere, get a local SIM, pop it in and you are good to go.
- justinsb 13y agoWithout getting into the whole rabbit-hole of monopolies/government good vs evil... Do you see any realistic alternative to an auction allocation system for mobile frequencies?
- ams6110 13y agoMaybe lottery? Though unless you had some restricitions on entry that might just result in the winners reselling their allocations to the established players for a profit.
- rayiner 13y agoAuctions are a superior solution to lotteries from an economic theoretical point of view. No point giving spectrum to a company that can't use it properly.
- hibikir 13y agoLotteries have been tried, and yes, it did lead to all kinds of work being done to be able to enter the lottery multiple times, for people to enter the lottery just to resell, and other similar shenanigans. More here: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/05/business/in-wireless-spectrum-competition-is-critical.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/05/business/in-wireless-spect... So a lottery quickly becomes a special kind of auction where lower bidders still have some chance to win.
- Retric 13y agoRather than have a tiny band for each company you could select a protocol for each band and let companies freely compete based on which has the lowest cost and a clear signal to each cellphone. Thus making it reasonable for 3rd party's to for example add a few towers near a convention center.
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoUnlicensed spectrum works extremely well for low power devices that don't cover long distances. If your roommate is using too much bandwidth you can hash it out together. The problem with using it for high power long distance frequencies is you get tragedy of the commons pretty much immediately. It would be interesting to try for the midrange though. Provide unlicensed spectrum at power levels that could cover e.g. a street rather than a city. Then you could get very local ISPs: One person on your street bites to bullet to buy a fast leased line for $$$ and then sells internet access to all the neighbors over wireless.
- badsock 13y agoThe mobile sector is a great example of a natural monopoly: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly In this case, competition is the problem not the solution. It makes no sense to build out massive cellular networks in triplicate. Connectivity could be provided much more efficiently at the municipal level, like water. Certainly, my experience with city water has been orders of magnitude more pleasant that with mobile providers, many times cheaper and more reliable, and I really don't see one as being harder to provide than the other.
- ams6110 13y agoWhy does it make sense to build out massive supermarket chains in triplicate?
- badsock 13y agoThe capital costs of supermarkets are much, much lower relative to their operating costs. However, using that context: contrast supermarkets with the roads that are used by both their suppliers and their consumers, and you have another good example of a capital-intesive infrastructure where redundancy is inefficient and therefore is better supplied by government.
- rlpb 13y ago> In this case, competition is the problem not the solution. It makes no sense to build out massive cellular networks in triplicate. I agree with you, but I also think that it makes no sense to grant access to the airwaves at the same time as granting a monopoly to all services that might be performed over those airwaves. I think that this effectively extends the monopoly into other areas that are not natural. In the UK, the incumbent telecoms company (BT) is required by the regulator to provide access to its lines to companies that compete with them. The (regulatory) agreed pricing is relatively close to BT's own cost structure (95 percentile billing, etc). This is just for the part that is the natural monopoly - primarily the last mile. The competition provide their own Internet backhaul, and sometimes the links to the exchanges too. I think this works remarkably well - the market has real competition in providing all of the other parts of Internet service (customer service, peering quality, how different ISPs end up managing their bandwidth, etc). With no history, I think it might be even better to limit companies granted rights to the natural monopoly area to only providing services to other businesses for access only. For example: a company granted access to cellphone frequencies might only be permitted to provide transit to other companies, rather than to retail customers directly. I think that by replacing the irrational retail customers with more rational businesses, we'd get better efficiency, real competition and prices closer to real cost.