4 ms·
It's called the Insurance Effect. People are willing to pay more for flat rate, which includes "carrying" high volume users, to insure against bill shock if the
by Zigurd 13y ago
It's called the Insurance Effect. People are willing to pay more for flat rate, which includes "carrying" high volume users, to insure against bill shock if their usage patterns change. Humans are bad at estimating bandwidth use, and pricing that removes that requirement has real value.
- _greim_ 13y agoIt may be hard to predict bandwidth usage, but electricity, gas, and water aren't perfectly predictable either, and unlike bandwidth we're incentivized to estimate them and to self-throttle to the extent reasonable (e.g. turn the thermostat down at night).
- saurik 13y ago"Insurance" is a form of risk mitigation. The reality of bandwidth is that we know someone who likes using FaceTime, or who has a Netflix subscription, is going to use more bandwidth than someone else. Sure: it makes sense if you aren't certain how large a web page will be to buy insurance on it, but you don't want to be in the same insurance bracket as a true "heavy user": I am happy to take part in a pool where everyone subsidizes the risk of accidental trauma, but I know someone who insists on smoking is going to increase their health costs, and they should be forced to take on that increased burden. This is especially evident when the playing field changes: the cost of insurance for all users goes up dramatically when something like FaceTime or Netflix is released, because the people using it are using dramatically more bandwidth than the people who aren't. If the bandwidth companies said "ok, thanks to Apple's FaceTime service, everyone's connection is now twice as expensive even if you don't own Apple hardware", people would be pissed. This is why insurance charges people differently for their inherent risk, and why you can't use insurance as a metaphor here (well, unless you want to make the opposite argument ;P).