6 ms·
"Tort reform" can seriously screw over people, because the parties that tend to favor tort reform (by which they mean greatly limiting the ability of people to
by tzs 13y ago
"Tort reform" can seriously screw over people, because the parties that tend to favor tort reform (by which they mean greatly limiting the ability of people to sue and/or the amount they can win if they do sue) also tend to favor limiting government regulation and oversight. That can leave nothing to compensate for the removal of the deterrence factor that the threat of lawsuits provides against bad corporate or professional behavior.
A sad example is provided by Texas. Protection against bad doctors was provided in Texas by three things: the Texas Medical Board, malpractice suits, and hospital managers. The legislature greatly limited the amount patients can win in malpractice suits, and they made it so hospitals cannot be held liable for hiring incompetent doctors unless the plaintiff can prove the hospital knew the doctor was an extreme risk and ignored this--and they made it so the plaintiff usually cannot get access to the documents that would be needed to prove this.
This shifted most of the burden of protecting Texans from bad doctors to the Texas Medical Board, which was not designed for that. It was more designed for licensing and ensuring that doctors keep with standards, not for investigating bad doctors. The Medical Board was not given any more resources to deal with this new and heavy workload, and so bad doctors could practice much longer than they would have been able to before the legislature decided to do their tort reform.
This article on the Dr. Christopher Duntsch case shows who wrong this can go: http://www.texasobserver.org/anatomy-tragedy/ http://www.texasobserver.org/anatomy-tragedy/
- rayiner 13y agoThe other thing is that common attempts at tort reform like damages caps address exactly the wrong problem. You're worried about frivolous suits, but the ones where juries are persuaded to award large damages are the least likely to be frivolous. Its good to note that BP had a limitation on damages that was like $50 million, which they waived.
- ensignavenger 13y agoThats an interesting perspective- any studies that show that Texas doctors are significantly worse than doctors in other states?
- DanBC 13y agoThe Guardian has an article that walks through the changes. It's pretty shocking. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/may/02/texas-legal-doctor-lawsuit-christopher-duntsch http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/may/02/texas-legal-doc... I too am interested to know if this means that there are more bad doctors in Texas. Having a colleague try to take the surgical instruments from you during a surgery because you are so incompetent sounds like an extreme yet the hospital did nothin after that incident.
- saryant 13y agoTexas has some of the best doctors in the world and an innovative healthcare community: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Medical_Center http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Medical_Center > The Texas Medical Center is the largest medical center in the world with one of the highest densities of clinical facilities for patient care, basic science, and translational research. Located in Greater Houston, the center contains 54 medicine-related institutions, including 21 hospitals and eight specialty institutions, eight academic and research institutions, three medical schools, six nursing schools, and schools of dentistry, public health, pharmacy, and other health-related practices. All 54 institutions are not-for-profit. The center exceeds one thousand acres (or 1.562 square mile) in size. [...] The Center is where one of the first and largest air ambulance services was created and where one of the first successful inter-institutional transplant programs was developed. More heart surgeries are performed in Texas Medical Center than anywhere else in the world. (Ironically, the TMC came about through a tax dodge)
- jasonwocky 13y ago>> any studies that show that Texas doctors are significantly worse than doctors in other states? > Texas has some of the best doctors in the world and an innovative healthcare community This doesn't answer the question.
- mturmon 13y agoI have to note the stereotypically Texan emphasis on sheer size in the above narrative.
- stuki 13y agoReputation systems, reviews and properly skeptical consumers, are what to aim for, in determining who is good and who is not. Whether for restaurants or doctors. Not frightfully pricey lawyers and other coercive, after-the-fact institutions. And, in the most egregious of cases, say McDonald's spiked granny's coffee with a hand grenade, the criminal courts get involved as a last ditch anyway. Reliance on civil courts may sound attractive to the naive, but the lawyers and institutions involved, are just as single mindedly focused on their own personal gains, financial and in prestige, as either party to the original dispute. It's not that they are necessarily systemically partial to one side or the other, but rather that they are partial to making the fight as acrimonious and expensive as possible. As that is, after all, their "side."
- karmajunkie 13y agoThe problem with that theory is that many doctors require patients to sign documents that prohibit online reviews, and many "bad reviews" from patients are somewhat frivolous. So reputation management is largely worthless in the medical field. Additionally, in Texas for example, tort reform has done nothing to limit costs of healthcare (though it has made malpractice insurance much cheaper, which makes life nice for doctors and their insurers.)
- stuki 13y agoAnd what kind of reputation, do you think an Amazon seller who makes potential customers sign "no review" contracts, will get? There's nothing magical about the medical field, that makes approaches developed elsewhere somewhat irrelevant there. It's just another fee for service arrangement. Although many Doctors do like to fancy themselves as special snowflakes.
- rictic 13y agoThat's some elegant rhetoric and ideology but it doesn't address the reality of the situation. The evidence that I see says that this has been a practice for at least five years, and according to the Boston Globe[2] one reason for this is that doctors feel like the conversation is one-sided, as they are legally forbidden from saying much about their patients. 1] http://boingboing.net/2009/03/05/doctors-force-patien.html http://boingboing.net/2009/03/05/doctors-force-patien.html 2] http://www.bostonglobe.com/lifestyle/health-wellness/2013/03/30/surgeon-suit-over-criticism-posted-online-patient-husband-part-wave-such-claims/TLAp5DOMpZISPevfLL6B1I/story.html http://www.bostonglobe.com/lifestyle/health-wellness/2013/03...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- qwerta 13y agoI have friend in Czech republic. Local hospital (or butchery as she called it) screw up routine procedure, so she gave birth in 7th month and can not have more babies. On damages she would get around $10.000, perhaps 5x more if she is celebrity with connections. That is not much money even in here, house costs usually around $100.000. I think US will have to give up right to sue in medical care. If you count expenses customers will still get better care. The amount you save on lawyers could go towards better care. And if doctors screws up, you will have good medical system to fix most damages, rather then going to court with some theoretical chances. And what could prevent bad doctors? Make gross neglect minor criminal offense. Doctor could go to jail for couple of weeks and loose its license. If enforced this would filter out bad doctors pretty quickly. And it could also force real safety practices such as recording procedures and operation check lists.
- spikels 13y agoNice theory but the reality is quite different. Medical care is far from a solved problem. For example if you are a teenager who gets an aortic aneurism (literal your heart is about to explode) in a car accident only 50% will survive even with the best care. How can cardiac surgeons afford to save half of these people if they know they will probably be sued by many of the other half with Texas juries awarding millions in damages for many of these statitically unavoidable deaths? They can't and neither can their insurers. For decades Texas juries were awarding so much money so often it became impossible for many high risk specialties, such as delivering babies (think of the downside versus upside), to get insured. In 2000 around a quarter of doctors in Texas were being sued for medical malpractice. Most insurance companies stopped writing insurance for doctors in Texas and the few remaining cooperatives faced bankruptcy. This is why both the Texas legislature and Texas voters (Prop 12) decided to limit damage awards in 2003 to what is now around an inflation adjusted $2 million per victim. Similar things happened in other states with California leading the way in the mid-1970s with a even more restrictive law (no inflation indexing - still the same $250,000 cap as 40 years ago)[1]. Remember the Texas lawyers and juries who have pretty much ruined the US patent system. I that who should an best police doctors? The Texas Medical Board seems like a pretty good approach: people with actual medical training and experience reviewing complaints about doctors. Maybe there is something better for getting rid of incompetent doctors than the Texas Medical Board (ideas pleae?) but unrestricted litigation proved unsustainable. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_Injury_Compensation_Reform_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_Injury_Compensation_Ref...
- jasonwocky 13y agoThe TMB taking this responsibility seems workable on face value; in a lot of ways, this correlates with how many European nations handle consumer protection: fewer lawsuits are permitted, but the bureaucracy increases its responsibility and authority. It seems like a pretty straightforward tradeoff with no obvious answer; just a tradeoff curve. When it fails is when, as grandparent indicates, the bureaucracy (TMB in this case) wasn't given enough additional resources to handle the increased workload.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoDon't get me wrong but isn't this the fault of the juries? Who by the way must also be the voters? I mean if you are happily awarding damages to heart surgeons who only save half their patients when the rest of the planet does not better, then the problem is in the jury box? no?
- brownbat 13y agoYeah, tort reform usually seeks to limit the punitive damages designed to make large institutions actually notice when they lose a lawsuit. Without such penalties, there's a reduced incentive for administrators to notice that, say, surgeons are frequently leaving scalpels in patients. [1] I get that people have an adverse reaction to plaintiffs striking it rich (not that they really are). But what tort reformers don't realize is that the perceived unfairness of jackpot lawsuits might actually be discouraging juries from using punitive damage amounts that would actually change corporate behavior. We might get more appropriate incentives for businesses if we said, "Ok, the plaintiff gets made whole, even for pain and suffering, maybe the lawyers get paid, but after that, punitives go to the state." The state could use the funds to educate or prevent harms similar to whatever most of the lawsuits are about, or set up a fund to compensate others harmed by the most common dangerous practices. It'd lead to damage awards that could actually change business behavior, fewer perceptions of unjust plaintiff enrichment, and a better balance sheet for the state or state programs designed to reduce the harms all at the same time. [1] http://www.everydayhealth.com/healthy-living/surgeons-leave-swabs-instruments-in-patients-8840.aspx http://www.everydayhealth.com/healthy-living/surgeons-leave-...