3 ms·
> Prosecuting a patent before the USPTO nearly always (+95%) involve an Office Action in which an Examiner at the USPTO searches the prior art and then presents
by Zigurd 13y ago
> Prosecuting a patent before the USPTO nearly always (+95%) involve an Office Action in which an Examiner at the USPTO searches the prior art and then presents one or more prior art based rejections.
I recently replied to a non-final office action on a patent I helped write. I was ready for battle, having 20 years ago rescued a patent written by other inventors that came back with dozens of patents cited as reading on it. It took days to research and respond to each item in that office action.
This time, the office action must have been written on Friday afternoon during a busy session on Farmville. Only the first few claims had specific references and the rest were rejected "by ditto." Only one patent was cited as reading on this patent. Responding was so easy I had to read the fairly brief office action three times to assure myself that was it.
Now that's just two data points, and maybe this newer patent is lucky to be for an unusually clearly novel device, but I have reasons to think it is in a field with lots of patents.
The difference in care taken by the examiner looks astounding. That first time I worked on saving a rejected patent, I ended up flying to DC with an expensive patent lawyer and demoing the invention to two examiners. Does that even happen anymore?
- makomk 13y agoI think standard practice these days is basically to reject most patent applications once and then accept them if the applicant bothers to resubmit - the USPTO doesn't have the resources to actually investigate applications in depth, and any examiner who tries is at risk of losing their job for not meeting their targets.