4 ms·
The FCC is (inadvertently) censoring my film
- lsiebert 13y agoClosed captioning doesn't have to be particularly good though, if live closed captioning is any indication. Why not just run it through a text to speech engine?
- stuaxo 13y agoI wonder if the fansub community could help?
- ggchappell 13y ago> I wonder if the fansub community could help? I'm sure they could, but they would first need to be allowed to help. See my other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7724124 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7724124
- lisper 13y agoI would be thrilled to have someone volunteer to close-caption my film. In fact, I'd even be willing to pay for it. But AFAICT it's not so easy to do. But maybe you know something I don't.
- IvyMike 13y agoSo I am just a guy on the internet, not an expert, but did you look into using "Amara"? It's not completely clear to me but it seems like it might be possible to get volunteers to do the transcription. They also claim to offer lower cost professional captioning services, too. http://www.amara.org/en/ http://www.amara.org/en/ If you do contact them, please consider sharing what you learn--I'm completely ignorant but willing to learn, and you might help the next guy. Good luck!
- lisper 13y agoNope, never heard of them until now. I'll look into it. Thanks!
- ggchappell 13y agoOr maybe you know something I don't. But consider: captioning is really nothing more than adding a bunch of text boxes to a media file. Each box needs placement (position/size), contents (the text), and timing (start/end). Given even passable software, this would not be difficult -- though it might be quite tedious.
- DanBC 13y agoHow hard would it be to add closed captioning? Why did film maker ignore the needs of some viewers when they made the film?
- lisper 13y agoIt would cost about $500. I "ignored" the needs of some viewers because I was completely clueless when I started making the film, and I was only slightly less clueless when I finished. It was not my intention to ignore the needs of the deaf community (in fact, I am generally a supporter of the deaf community) but it just never occurred to me that a deaf person would want to see it. In fact, if there is even a single deaf person out there who wants to see this film, it would surprise me.
- DanBC 13y agoEven for guerilla filmmaking $500 is not much. I donrecognise that it is a sum of cash that might be seen as not needed. Perhaps Kickstarter could help here? "I have a product that is almost finished. Now I just want to do the final bits. I believe everyone should be able to access this film so I want to add closed captioning and audio description for hearing impaired and sight impaired audience." Sorry for seeming cross in my first post.
- qq66 13y agoEverything in existence ignores the needs of someone (except maybe air and water). Even the closed-captioned version would ignore the needs of the blind.
- DanBC 13y agoWhich is why I also mentioned audio description in my follow up posts. Saying that everything is inaccessible by default, and always has been, is not an excuse to continue to not provide very simple accessibility.
- ggchappell 13y agoI see where the writer is coming from, but, as someone with lousy hearing, I find it difficult to sympathize. Part of me wants to yell, "Quit moaning and just caption your film!" But there are difficulties. The writer has a life, I'm sure, and lots of other things to do. The irony is that I'm sure there are people who would be happy to do it for him. Some of them might do it free. And for someone with experience and the proper software, I imagine a passable job might take a day and an excellent job might take two days. The main barrier, I would guess, is legal rights. You generally cannot legally take someone else's film and modify it, without their permission -- no matter how altruistic your motives are. What we need is a standard way to cut through the legal barriers. Perhaps a document could be drawn up that makes the right to add accomodations for disabilities (in an accurate manner) available to all, while leaving other rights unmodified. Then small filmmakers could just indicate that their work falls under these terms.[1] A nicer alternative would be for a law to be passed that applies such terms to all creative works. But I don't expect that to happen any time soon. [1] EDIT. Or maybe something like this already exists. Does anyone know?
- DanBC 13y agoA crowd sourced website where rights owners to low budget films can ask for closed captioning (and audio description) would be great. With some kind of version control the captions can get incrementally better. This would work well for text - captions and suntitle translations - but not so well for audio description. You monetise the site with donations from film makers and from charities wanting better accessibility.
- IvyMike 13y agoTo those saying that the $200-$800 shouldn't be a factor: Some time in 2004, I went to a pre-release screening of a movie in Hollywood. The director was there, and afterwards he did a Q&A. Someone asked "Is there anything you would have changed about your movie?" The director's response: "If I had had $400 more, I would have [filmed a scene much differently]". So the immediate follow-up was "Wait, $400? How much did your movie cost?" The answer: $7000. It turns out that you may have even heard of this particular movie: it was Shane Carruth's Primer. It's one of those small indie films that managed to break out and make a profit. But I guarantee for every Primer there are 100 other films that don't make it, and some of them are quite good. The question is do we really want to lose access to those films? (I personally think the answer is trying to get that $800 down to under $100 through automation and tools, but we're not there yet.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primer_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primer_(film)
- lisper 13y agoI'm the filmmaker and the author of the blog post. The total budget for "But for the Grace of God?" was about $10k. It depends a little on how you count. I spent $2k on equipment (mainly an HDV camera), $1k on software (Final Cut Pro), $3k on editing (all of which was ultimately wasted because I ended up editing the whole film myself) and $2k on music licensing, plus some miscellaneous expenses. Close-captioning would cost about $500 or so, or about 5% of the total budget, or about 50% of what the film has made.
- washadjeffmad 13y agoYeah, but this is maybe a ten hour job for an amateur using free (OSS) tools, and it's to keep a much bigger investment where it can make money. Estimate about three hours per hour of footage to transcribe, then two to three times the length of the film to sync the subtitles and, if required, embed. You could have knocked it out in a weekend then written a blog exploring what technical and formal steps you took to comply, which would have been a much more apt and interesting topic to see on HN. Calling it censorship is a bit much, but I get the frustrating sentiment that is keeping up with compliance.