3 ms·
If the API headers are copyrighted, wouldn't any program that uses them be a derivative work? In that light, every Java program is infringing. Every program on
by phkahler 13y ago
If the API headers are copyrighted, wouldn't any program that uses them be a derivative work? In that light, every Java program is infringing. Every program on earth would be infringing something wouldn't it?
- Pxtl 13y agoTo be fair, the free software foundation takes the opinion that using a library is a derivative work of that library, which is why they provide both the GPL and the LGPL. If using a library was not a derivative work of that library, then there would be no need for an LGPL.
- belorn 13y agoLGPL has nothing to do with API, but rather the definition of a derivative work. Using a library i akin to put a engine into a car. One could argue that the engine would still be a separate piece and thus not "part of the car", but its a tough sell to do in court. The line that separate "a thing" with "other things" is determined by judges, juries (and in some cases, common sense). In 23 years, no one has dared yet to do so. Using an API however is like putting your own engine into the car, but it happens to use the same input/output of similar car engines. The GPL do not have a dog in that fight, but FSF argues against such stretching of copyright.
- phkahler 13y agoThe existence of the LGPL has always seemed liked a solution to what would otherwise be a grey area to me, and I thought FSF thought that too. Not sure they come down clearly on the one side. I know some of the Linux kernel people think that way too. Interesting.
- jboy55 13y agoThe API headers are copyrighted, and any program that uses them is a derivative work. However, the license you accept in using the copyrighted work allows you to do so, with some conditions. Google chose to ignore those conditions. API headers being copyrightable protects a lot of GPL'd code too, this ruling protects FOSS as much as it hurts Java.
- as_someone 13y ago> every Java program is infringing No, for a couple reasons: 1. Those programs aren't distributing the material in question. You, the user, will have independently acquired the JRE. This will have most likely been through non-infringing means, given that Sun/Oracle lets you have it for free, and even if it were infringing, you'd be the one at fault, not the program author. 2. Even if that weren't true, there would still be a couple of options to create a non-infringing program. Only programs that are neither non-GPL, nor those from authors who have some other valid commercial license would be infringing. Not "every Java program".