3 ms·
First, I don't think the court ruled infringement -- only copyrightability. Second, not too many open source projects implement proprietary APIs. FOSS today do
by pron 13y ago
First, I don't think the court ruled infringement -- only copyrightability.
Second, not too many open source projects implement proprietary APIs. FOSS today does not get its value from producing fully compatible clones of proprietary software.
Third, proprietary software vendors will face the choice of limiting the use of their APIs (i.e. copying) by OSS and risk reduced adoption, or allow it to get wide adoption and offer a superior implementation. I'm not sure most would choose the former.
So with the state of FOSS today, I don't see how such a decision changes much. I would very much like to hear if people have counterexamples (other than WINE).
- Oletros 13y ago> First, I don't think the court ruled infringement -- only copyrightability. The jury ruled infringement in the Oracle - Google trial
- bmvakili 13y agoBut deadlocked on Google's fair use.
- Oletros 13y agoYap, 9-3 in Google favor
- bmvakili 13y agoAm I reading this wrong or what's missing? "Because we conclude that the declaring code and the structure, sequence, and organization of the API packages are entitled to copyright protection, we reverse the district court’s copyrightability determination with instructions to reinstate the jury’s infringement finding as to the 37 Java packages. Because the jury deadlocked on fair use, we remand for further consideration of Google’s fair use defense in light of this decision. With respect to Google’s cross-appeal, we affirm the district court’s decisions: (1) granting Oracle’s motion for JMOL as to the eight decompiled Java files that Google copied into Android; and (2) denying Google’s motion for JMOL with respect to the rangeCheck function. Accordingly, we affirm-in-part, reverse-in-part, and remand for further proceedings."
- Oletros 13y agoYes, you read right. Jury was deadlocked with 9 juries supporting fair use and 3 saying that there was not fair use