3 ms·
There's really no solution to this problem. It's obvious you disagree with the outcome, but equally obviously many would agree... he certainly didn't have the a
by jerf 13y ago
There's really no solution to this problem. It's obvious you disagree with the outcome, but equally obviously many would agree... he certainly didn't have the agency to give a solid answer by most of our standards (apparently some here disagree). There's no good solution, nor would I even agree there's a "default answer" here per se that we can fall back to. In the end all you can possibly end up with is a power struggle over whose personal preferences are going to be followed.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoSure there's a good solution! Don't saw his head open on TV! Anybody can see that is a very dodgy move by anybody's standards.
- phkahler 13y agoI have to agree here. The default would be to dispose of his body in a traditional way. There could be arguments about burial or cremation or maybe some other tradition I don't know about, but no one thinks of thin-slicing the head as any kind of default in todays (or yesterdays) world. I find the question of how this got approved almost as interesting as the original story. I can only think of 3 ways to decide: 1) prior consent from a parent 2) just ask him even though his brain is not normal 3) politics. Debating the legitimacy of #2 is really just going with option #3.