3 ms·
How much of this work is the result of the US tax system?
by protomyth 13y ago
How much of this work is the result of the US tax system?
- rayiner 13y agoYou mean the finance work? Although almost all of it has tax implications, most actual tax work is handled by accounting and law firms. The finance folks do the bread and butter of corporate financial transactions and asset management. They underwrite IPO's, put together bond issues, arrange lines of credit, and work out mergers and divestitures. Very little of it arises due to the tax system. Even the law firms doing the legal side of these transactions don't devote huge resources to tax. The NYC firm where I used to work, which had a top-rated tax practice, had about 1/10 as many lawyers working on tax matters as they did working on M&A or securities matters. I'd imagine the accounting firms have a higher percentage of tax people, though.
- protomyth 13y agoSo, if a federal flat-rate tax[1] was set, it wouldn't significantly reduce the workload? 1) revenue * tax rate = taxes (asking question, not advocating)
- rayiner 13y agoA flat tax isn't revenue * tax_rate. It's income * tax_rate. You have to subtract expenses from revenue, otherwise your tax is totally arbitrary. A company like Wal-Mart makes 5-6% operating income on revenues, after paying for rent, workers, inventory, etc. Even a 10% tax on revenue would wipe them out. Most of the work in taxes is getting from revenue down to taxable income, and after that it's just a number you plug into a spreadsheet. For individuals, a flat tax would make calculating taxes much easier, but that's because their tax situation is dead simple to begin with. But for a business, you still have hard issues like depreciation rates for capital equipment, carryforwards, etc, and those don't go away with a flat tax. And in any case, none of this has much to do with the finance industry. They might ask their tax lawyer: "what's the tax implications of spinning off this subsidiary as a separate company?" and a simpler tax code might reduce that bill, but it's not work they'd be doing themselves. Their job in that situation would be to plan and analyze the divestiture. What kind of cash flow will the stand-alone company have? What assets should go with it? Then the lawyers will get involved and do stuff like draft the asset purchase agreement between the seller and the buyer, or the agreement that allows the spun-off company to continue to use certain IP belonging to the seller. And the accountants will, well, do the accounting for all of this. None of this work goes away just because the tax code is simpler.
- protomyth 13y agoyeah, I should have put income. I was pretty much asking if tax law was driving some of the hours - guess not.
- danielweber 13y agoI believe there a lot of things that we could do to EDIT FIX TYPO _simplify_ tax work (say, kill the corporate tax and replace it with a consumption tax and/or taxes on capital gains/dividends until we have the same revenue). But, as 'rayiner says, changing the five-line tax table into a one-line tax table is not where the current complexity is.