3 ms·
You're acting like we would actually run out of fuel. That will never happen. Instead certain fuels will get cheaper and others will be more expensive. Only a
by ars 13y ago
You're acting like we would actually run out of fuel. That will never happen. Instead certain fuels will get cheaper and others will be more expensive.
Only a tiny faction of fuel is used for airplanes - so save all the hydrocarbons for them, and use the other energy sources for land based things. (And if necessary it's not that hard to make hydrocarbon fuel from sunlight and air - you can pretend the hydrocarbons are a battery.)
We have enough energy sources on this planet excluding sunlight for over 100,000 years. And that includes population growth! Include the local asteroids and the sun and we have enough for longer than I care to predict.
Pessimism like yours has been a constant for hundreds of years now, and it repeatedly makes the same error: It assumes no change, just the continuation of existing trends.
There is some value in it, in that it makes us more frugal, but let's not overdo it.
- dredmorbius 13y agoYou're acting like we would actually run out of fuel. So, tell me, what's your alternative energy supply budget look like? Please provide references and sources for consumption and reserves. What's your population estimate? Additionally, how do you account for: climate change, sea level rise, phosphorus depletion, topsoil loss? Thanks. FYI: Aviation fuel is about 13% of total US petroleum consumption. 36,017 million gallons in 2012, of 6.748 billion barrels of oil consumed. Sources: http://www.faa.gov/data_research/aviation/aerospace_forecasts/2001-2012/media/Table%2022.pdf http://www.faa.gov/data_research/aviation/aerospace_forecast... http://www.eia.gov/countries/country-data.cfm?fips=US http://www.eia.gov/countries/country-data.cfm?fips=US
- ars 13y ago> So, tell me, what's your alternative energy supply budget look like? http://www-formal.stanford.edu/jmc/progress/cohen.html http://www-formal.stanford.edu/jmc/progress/cohen.html 4 Billion years worth of Uranium on earth. And there's 4 times as much thorium. So 20 billion years then. We're using about 3 times as much energy per year as when the paper was written, but then again we've found more uranium since then. Even if you want to cut the number in half to account for those that's still 10 billion years - cut it by 10 if you like, for energy usage increase, and that's still 1 billion years. It doesn't matter what adjustment factors you want to use (more energy usage, more uranium found), we aren't going to ever run out. > Additionally, how do you account for: climate change, sea level rise, phosphorus depletion, topsoil loss? Climate change and sea level rise are non issues since nuclear power will be widespread before those things cause any problems. Phosphorus is never actually depleted - it just gets moved from one place to another, it's not possible to actually use it up. If it gets expensive (note: expensive, not rare) it will be profitable to mine it from sewage and the mouths of rivers (which is where it goes). Same for topsoil, the nutrients that make it good don't get used up, they just get moved into plants. Eat the plant, then put it back. > Aviation fuel is about 13% of total US petroleum consumption. I said energy consumption, only 1/3 of which is oil. Don't forget we can make aviation fuel from energy plus air (or preferably some coal and water). And we have a LOT of coal, if we stopped using it for energy and instead made it a feedstock for carbon in aviation hydrocarbons we'll never run out. Better would be to get carbon from plant waste, hulls, straw, etc. Remove the carbon and make fuel, remove the potassium and make fertilizer. All you need is energy to make this work.
- dredmorbius 13y agoI strongly dispute Cohen's claims on available uranium. US government estimates are that there's a ~80 year supply of uranium as a small fraction of present total electrical generation. That falls to 6 years if all global energy is to be supplied from extant uranium reserves. Claims that uranium can be feasibly extracted from seawater are interesting, and though I waive final judgement, I'm not convinced. I've addressed a 62,000 year supply estimate for thorium. The author makes a massibe substantive underestimation of present total energy consumption. Correcting for this, using his abundance and reserves estimates the supply is good for 42 years: http://redd.it/23nvqs http://redd.it/23nvqs NB: Thorium is not present in seawater at any appreciable concentration, and the uranium seawater trick doesn't apply. Climate change and sea level rise are non issues since nuclear power will be widespread before those things cause any problems. There's a baked-in several-degrees rise already, and a very significant lag in concentrations and climate effects. We'll be seeing the consequences, it's a matter of how much and for how long. I've seen estimates of 300 - 1000 years for the atmospheric CO2 balance to return to preindustrial levels even if all human emissions cease. See: http://www.nature.com/climate/2008/0812/full/climate.2008.122.html http://www.nature.com/climate/2008/0812/full/climate.2008.12... http://blogs.edf.org/climate411/2008/02/26/ghg_lifetimes/ http://blogs.edf.org/climate411/2008/02/26/ghg_lifetimes/ There's also the problem that a large portion of carbon emissions aren't due to fossil fuel emissions directly: concrete, agriculture, deforestation, and cattle are all sources. As well as other greenhouse gasses, some with higher effects than CO2, some with longer atmospheric residency. It's complicated (and no, I'm not fully versed in specifics). But these will continue to have to be addressed. Same for topsoil, the nutrients that make it good don't get used up Topsoil itself is eroding and being washed away. The soils of the great plains have literally decreased, by many feet, since farming and ploughing began in the mid-19th century. Nutrients aren't merely taken up by plants but are then transported off the farmland, to be eaten and dispersed. Added nutrients wash away with irrigation water fouling rivers (don't move along the lower Mississippi if you can help it) and forming offshore dead zones in the Gulf of Mexico, Yellow Sea, and elsewhere, due to algae blooms and oxygen starvation. You're ... well out of your depth and highly underinformed (or misinformed) on all these points. Don't forget we can make aviation fuel from energy plus air I've addressed that multiple times elsewhere on this post. I see seawater rather than air as a CO2 + H2 feedstock as being much more viable. It's still tremendously energy intensive, and my estimate is that replacing present US petroleum consumption would likely cost ~$16 - $24 trillion between the fuel synthesis and energy inputs. I consider that plausible (amortize the costs over 40 years, roughly $2000 per man woman and child at the low end, about 4% of GDP over that period). Assuming the estimates hold. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7718584 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7718584 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7719535 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7719535 Better would be to get carbon from plant waste, hulls, straw, etc. Bullshit. Not nearly enough biomass: http://globalecology.stanford.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange1.pdf http://globalecology.stanford.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange... Again: you're way out of your depth here. Get educated.