3 ms·
No, no, no. This blasted video (which just won't stay down) is anti-knowledge. It leaves the viewer with the satisfied feeling that they understand something de
by jerf 17y ago
No, no, no. This blasted video (which just won't stay down) is anti-knowledge. It leaves the viewer with the satisfied feeling that they understand something deep and profound, while actually leaving them less informed about mathematics and physics simultaneously, in that it builds in resistance to the actually true and correct ideas. This has no value whatsoever, not even to attract people to the field, since the field it is espousing does not exist. In fact, it has less than no value. It is one of the most pernicious memes of this type I have ever seen.
Watch this video, if only so you know what sort of total bullshit you need to watch out for if you try to learn about real physics or math. See that feeling it gives you, that feeling of understanding? Train yourself to run from it, because it's wrong.
- I_got_fifty 17y agoInsightful. I do wonder what you think of http://www.dimensions-math.org/ http://www.dimensions-math.org/ it seems to be more math focused, but is it too just techno-babble with pretty pictures?
- diiq 17y agoIt's good stuff, but it never gets around to talking about higher dimensional space; it feels unfinished.
- helveticaman 17y agoSo it's fake yet satisfying. Would it be like porn for the intellect, then?
- tel 17y agoIf something claims to be scientific but leaves you with less questions than you came in with it's lying.
- eru 17y agoI agree. And they can't even pronounce Möbius strip. (The narrator says Mobius strip.)
- bradgessler 17y agoCan you post a link to some research that conclusively proves string theory being completely, totally wrong? If not, then let string theory stand as a hypothesis, but don't totally dismiss it (or dismiss it, you may or may not be wrong). Also, if you think somebody is going to take a 10 minute web video as the answer to the universe (everybody knows it 42) and a substitute for an ungodly amount of science, research, and knowledge then you have mistaken.
- mnemonicsloth 17y agoPeople who take issue with string theory do so precisely because what you're asking is impossible (in their view, anyway). Various technical properties of the theory (like the fact that it represents only a description of an uncountably infinite class of possible mathematical theories) make it impossible to disprove. See, for example: http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/ http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/ None of which has anything to do with the problems in the video. Those are more of the "subtle, pernicious category mistake" variety.
- jerf 17y agoThe only thing that video has to do with string theory is that it contains the words "string theory". Go read "The Elegant Universe" instead. (Don't watch the PBS series, read the book. It's not the be-all, end-all of string theory, but it's actual knowledge, not anti-knowledge.) Criticizing this video is not criticizing string theory; this video would be vastly improved if it actually contained any sort of truth about string theory. Being short is not an excuse for being grotesquely wrong. Not simplified, which has its place, but wrong.