4 ms·
Planes get about 90 mpg, and trains about 450. The difference is there, but it's not all that dramatic. It's enough to have a difference in cost, but not a diff
by ars 13y ago
Planes get about 90 mpg, and trains about 450. The difference is there, but it's not all that dramatic. It's enough to have a difference in cost, but not a difference in availability.
Planes are more efficient than cars, so why do you think aviation of all things will become too expensive to be viable?
You have an unrealistically pessimistic view on things. Fuel will only get cheaper, not more expensive.
- rayiner 13y agoFuel has been getting more expensive for decades, which has had a massive impact on the world economy. Also, writing off a factor of five, when talking about an industry (transportation) where engineers would kill puppies for another 5%.
- ars 13y ago> Fuel has been getting more expensive for decades No it hasn't. You are forgetting to adjust for inflation: http://inflationdata.com/Inflation/images/charts/Oil/Gasoline_inflation_chart.htm http://inflationdata.com/Inflation/images/charts/Oil/Gasolin... And that graph is gasoline - if you graphed all energy it would look even better. http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/steo/realprices/ http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/steo/realprices/ (too bad it's not logarithmic - it's hard to read without it). It's basically only the last decade that prices went up - before that it was all down. > Also, writing off a factor of five, when talking about an industry (transportation) where engineers would kill puppies for another 5%. I'm not writing off the difference I'm saying that the difference is not enough to make it "non viable" - just more expensive. If we were going to cut back on things because of energy costs, aviation is not what we would cut.
- mark-r 13y agoHow much of the inflation rate is tied to the cost of fuel? It's built in to just about everything we buy or produce.
- dredmorbius 13y agoThat, IMO, is a very interesting question. Arguably, prices should be specified by energy input requirements, with energy's own cost being largely defined by its own EROEI. This is modulated (but not eliminated) by technological capabilities. Charles A.F. Hall has developed this idea among others. Look up thermoeconomics / biophysical economics / ecological economics for more on this theme. Santa Fe Institute and the EconoPhysics Forum also have some interesting work: http://www3.unifr.ch/econophysics/ http://www3.unifr.ch/econophysics/
- dredmorbius 13y agoFuel has been getting more expensive in real terms off and on since US peak production in 1972. It's soared since 2000. BP's annual energy outlook is one of the best sources for historical price information: http://www.bp.com/en/global/corporate/about-bp/energy-economics/statistical-review-of-world-energy-2013/review-by-energy-type/oil/oil-prices.html http://www.bp.com/en/global/corporate/about-bp/energy-econom... Otherwise, I agree with you that a factor of five is not negligible.
- kingnothing 13y agoGas was under $1 / gal less than 15 years ago. Now it's over $5 / gal in many parts of the US. How do you see it getting cheaper over time?
- ars 13y ago15 years ago was the lowest price gas has ever been. It fell dramatically to get to that point. If I had talked to you 15 years ago you would comment on how gas keeps getting cheaper. It's corrected a bit since then, but adjusted for inflation and taking the long view it's not very expensive right now. http://inflationdata.com/Inflation/images/charts/Oil/Gasoline_inflation_chart.htm http://inflationdata.com/Inflation/images/charts/Oil/Gasolin...
- dredmorbius 13y agoIt was cheap, but cheaper in real terms from the late 1920s through the end of the 1960s. And very nearly from the 1870s, with a few minor exceptions (1890s, 1910 - 1925). NB: I'm looking at the cost of oil not necessarily of refined gasoline, using BP's reporting. The post-2000 price is unprecedented in the prior century. Note too that the US price was stabilized through production quotas established by the Texas Railroad Commission, in place from 1945 - 1971. They were lifted as US peak oil occurred, and extraction rates could not be increased. This set the stage for the 1973-74 oil embargo (earlier attempts at middle-east oil embargoes had been tried, but were not successful due to excess US extraction capacity). http://www.bp.com/en/global/corporate/about-bp/energy-economics/statistical-review-of-world-energy-2013/review-by-energy-type/oil/oil-prices.html http://www.bp.com/en/global/corporate/about-bp/energy-econom...
- dredmorbius 13y agoA 777 gets 60 passenger MPG, or roughly 5.9 ton-miles/gallon. A train achieves 100 - 500 ton-miles/gallon. A ship such as the Emma Maersk achieves about 1500 ton miles/gallon. Moreover, if it gets down to it, a ship or train can drag the additional fuel it needs along with it, even if that is some multiples less energy dense than present hydrocarbons. Aircraft are limited by their lifting capacity, and under most scenarios, the battery weight required (assuming conventional batteries) would exceed the maximum takeoff weight. Though ships require prodigious amounts of fuel and travel long distances, I ran some calculations suggesting you could run the Emma off of LiON batteries -- they'd only take up about half her cargo capacity. I still don't think you'd want to. I have a hard time seeing fuel getting cheaper, though among the benefits of, say, a solar-driven electricity-to-fuel synthesis using seawater as carbon and hydrogen feedstock is that the cost would be constant. Your sunlight and water aren't going to go away or get more expensive over even geological time, and PV is also based on an abundant material (silicon, plus dopants). So long as population is kept in check, you've got an option for a constant-cost fuel supply for the future. Even if that's more expensive than today, assuming the net cycle EROEI is below a technological civilization sustaining threshold (estimated at between 6:1 and 9:1 by Charles A.F. Hall), we might pull things off. Then there's just other resources and pollution issues to be concerned with.
- ars 13y agoYou're acting like we would actually run out of fuel. That will never happen. Instead certain fuels will get cheaper and others will be more expensive. Only a tiny faction of fuel is used for airplanes - so save all the hydrocarbons for them, and use the other energy sources for land based things. (And if necessary it's not that hard to make hydrocarbon fuel from sunlight and air - you can pretend the hydrocarbons are a battery.) We have enough energy sources on this planet excluding sunlight for over 100,000 years. And that includes population growth! Include the local asteroids and the sun and we have enough for longer than I care to predict. Pessimism like yours has been a constant for hundreds of years now, and it repeatedly makes the same error: It assumes no change, just the continuation of existing trends. There is some value in it, in that it makes us more frugal, but let's not overdo it.