3 ms·
How come these things never look refined and polished? Always sort of half nice and Unix-clunk.
by andrewstuart 13y ago
How come these things never look refined and polished? Always sort of half nice and Unix-clunk.
- scythe 13y agoPersonally I think it's the goddamn panel; I've never seen a Linux panel that looks as nice as its counterparts on Windows and OS X. It seems like a small component, but it really "frames" the whole desktop environment -- like a drumbeat -- and in both OS X and Windows there are some complicated gradients in the panel that I'm almost certain were insisted on by some tweed-clad hipster with a title half a sentence long; to my eye it really does make a difference. The windows actually look really nice, especially considering it's the default skin.
- andrewstuart 13y agoUnix desktops always seem to have weird inconsistent margins and fonts that somehow don't look right. Just doesn't feel nice.
- kijin 13y agoIt takes a professional designer (or rather, a dozen of them) to produce a professional-looking desktop theme. Which is exactly what the majority of FOSS projects lack. When you let a programmer dictate the design, you end up with a lot of features and a lot of misaligned margins. In my experience, many programmers just don't care about pixel-perfect designs. Yes, I'm talking about the same group of people who scoff at typography because "the content is the only thing that matters", blah blah blah. Admittedly, I have no data to back this up, but I have a gut feeling that lightweight desktop environments are particularly teeming with this "function before form" crowd. When you treat design as a second-class citizen of your project, it's no wonder you can't attract good designers to work with you. On the other hand, when you let a designer dictate the design, you end up with perfectly aligned margins and anti-aliased corners, but all the features and configuration options you care about are hidden behind five clicks and a keyboard shortcut, or worse, removed entirely because they somehow violate the designer's philosophy :(
- andrewstuart 13y agoOSX seems to make it very smooth.
- jqm 13y agoOut of the box yes, generally clunky. But those I have played with, KDE, XFCE etc. (disclaimer.. I haven't tried this one) are generally very tunable and can look quite nice when customized. I agree with poster who mentions the panel though. Usually they aren't so good. Although with a semi-transparent panel my KDE desktop looks pretty good to me at least.
- scrollaway 13y agoGraphics people are a lot harder to find in open source and on an open source budget. I'm sure if you have graphics skills and propose them to them they will jump on the occasion.
- userbinator 13y agoFunny you mention this, since I've noticed that even in ReactOS - which is supposed to be a Windows clone - there's something "not quite right" about it when you look at a screenshot like http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-SN0tgsoHkV8/UwMdmx3RM1I/AAAAAAAAA3U/RM7N_g_-Isk/s1600/ReactOS_Project._The_windows_open_source.png http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-SN0tgsoHkV8/UwMdmx3RM1I/AAAAAAAAA3... - I think it's mostly the fonts. I've found that free (as in freedom) fonts just have this... odd look to them.
- Zirro 13y agoFonts do make a big difference. In the case of ReactOS however, the version you are showing seems to be from 2008. This is from a current version: http://cl.ly/image/0c0U1Q3l3Y1C http://cl.ly/image/0c0U1Q3l3Y1C