4 ms·
Can someone explain to me why it should be illegal for Ford or Chevy to sell their cars directly? Is it really anti-competitive? Apple sells their phones direct
by freehunter 13y ago
Can someone explain to me why it should be illegal for Ford or Chevy to sell their cars directly? Is it really anti-competitive? Apple sells their phones directly, AT&T sells Apple phones directly, and resellers like Best Buy or Radio Shack sell Apple phones, and they're all doing pretty well economically.
Not even arguing that Tesla should be allowed to sell cars without a dealership, why bother preventing direct sales from manufacturers, but only for this specific product category?
- masterleep 13y agoBecause money flows from dealerships to politicians, that's why.
- xrjn 13y agoThere's an excellent Planet Money episode on this issue: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/12/171814201/episode-435-why-buying-a-car-is-so-awful http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/12/171814201/episode-... But in brief, there is basically a vested power that does not want to allow innovation to disrupt their highly profitable industry. They rely on some fairly outdated laws to protect themselves.
- tdiggity 13y agoAs an example - Official Apple Stores have hurt mom&pop Apple stores. Apple ultimately makes money either way, but they make more money if they sell them at their own Apple store. Why would you go to the mom&pop store if an Apple store were nearby? There have also been reports that they don't give the 3rd party shops new models until much later, so they are at even more of a disadvantage. Try buying that new Macbook Pro the day it's released at a 3rd party store. It probably won't be available. Back in the day, the dealers banded together so that wouldn't happen to them by making it law.
- mikeash 13y agoOne thing I don't understand is why the dealers didn't play the manufacturers off each other to mitigate the problems. I can see that, for Apple dealers, it could be a major problem. Apple products are a specific niche, and you can't take your Apple dealer and turn it into something else with much hope of success. Selling PCs is a pretty different business. But when it comes to car, surely selling Fords is much the same as selling Toyotas? If Toyota treated a dealership badly, why wouldn't they shop around for a brand that would treat them better? Is it that the American car manufacturing industry wasn't sufficiently competitive for that to work when these laws were being written?
- mortenjorck 13y agoI'm going to guess there's a pretty strong non-compete built into the standard dealership contract.
- jessaustin 13y agoBut there are many dealerships that have like ten different brands?
- mikeash 13y agoYeah, definitely doesn't seem to be the case around here. Some local dealers are just one company, but some represent a vast quantity, e.g.: http://ourisman.com/ http://ourisman.com/ http://www.koons.com/ http://www.koons.com/ http://www.lindsaycars.com/ http://www.lindsaycars.com/
- andrewtbham 13y agoDealerships fear if auto companies sold directly to the public they would undercut their prices.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 13y agoThe original intent of these laws was to protect franchisees, who may work very hard to develop a local market, from manufactures later coming in to that same area with direct sales, effectively stealing the market from the franchisee who identified and developed it. The Tesla argument, which makes sense to me, is that since they have no franchise dealers, there is no reason to prohibit them from selling direct.
- pdq 13y agoIt is protectionism for the dealerships. Historically Dealerships were mom and pop shops up in less-populated towns, employing a decent number of people. So they lobby the government that unless you protect us from the dealers, they will undercut our prices by selling directly to consumers, and we will have to lay off some of our employees, or go out of business. Then our small town won't have said dealerships anymore. Especially now that we have the internet, these policies are antiquated and end up hurting consumers, by driving up prices. Without the middle-man, cars could be sold at lower prices.
- msandford 13y agoThere's also the way the business evolved. Manufacturers don't have unlimited funds to: 1) design cars 2) design factories 3) manufacture cars 4) retail cars So somewhere along the line someone figured out that cars are somewhat commodity, same as clothing or food. A grocery store sells several brands of food and department stores sell several brands of clothing. Cars could be done the same way. Manufacturers liked it because it allowed them to grow much faster by selling franchise licenses and use that money for design of cars, factories and to actually build cars. It's an all around win. But eventually manufacturers grow to the point where they aren't starved for capital anymore, have good market penetration and growth starts to slow. So a natural next step is to cut out the middlemen (the dealers who have paid franchise fees) and start direct-to-consumer sales efforts. This idea didn't sit well with the dealers who had paid those franchise fees and might have assumed they could amortize them over many years. So laws got passed preventing manufacturers from competing with the dealers that they had sold franchises to. But Tesla has never sold anyone a franchise ever. They're not doing naughty things to their former customers (the dealers) because they've never had dealers. REQUIRING them to sell only to dealers doesn't make sense unless you're worried about Ford doing some kind of shady restructuring to get themselves out of all their dealer contracts and to start selling direct to consumers.
- frogpelt 13y agoIt may help to view this set of laws the same way that some people view labor unions. Labor unions started with positive intentions and were needed to protect workers who were often overworked and underpaid. Now many feel that labor unions mostly exist to support themselves and make it harder on everyone from corporations to consumers and their effects aren't near as beneficial as they once were. The internet has made direct-to-consumer sales a much more viable alternative and the car industry has yet to realize it. By the way, cars aren't the only products sold this way. Try to buy a Stihl chainsaw or a John Deere mower without going through a dealership. Try to buy a traditional name brand mattress or piece of furniture direct from the manufacturer. There is a start up born nearly every day trying to "disrupt" this business model.
- mikeash 13y agoAre Stihl and John Deere dealerships protected by law, or is that just how the business arrangements shook out? There's nothing wrong with the dealership model per se, but it's troublesome when it becomes mandated by law.
- awjr 13y agoStihl have a business model based around dealerships.
- smackfu 13y ago> Apple sells their phones directly, AT&T sells Apple phones directly, and resellers like Best Buy or Radio Shack sell Apple phones, and they're all doing pretty well economically. The trick is that they are actually three different business models. Apple makes money on the phones. AT&T makes money on the phone contract. Best Buy or Radio Shack make money on the protection plans and accessories.
- jcampbell1 13y agoLet's say you borrow money, and open a nice profitable dealership. The manufacturer, then decides to steal your profits by raising the wholesale price of cars for you until you are bankrupt, and the manufacturer buys the dealership out from under you in bankruptcy court. That type of behavior is what created franchise laws in the first place.
- dpe82 13y agoYou shouldn't have opened the dealership without an agreement with the manufacturer giving you exclusive rights to sell in your market for enough time to justify your investment.
- jcampbell1 13y agoHow would that matter? You are bankrupt, so you'd be forced to sell the rights to pay back the bank.
- dpe82 13y agoApologies: exclusivity and price guarantees.
- gamblor956 13y agoOnce upon a time, such agreements were considered anti-competitive. Hence, states passed franchise laws providing similar protections without the exclusivity agreements.
- jessaustin 13y agoThat smells like a just-so story. The grim scenario you describe could happen in any franchise situation. What stops McDonald's from doing this to its franchisees? Not this type of law.
- gamblor956 13y agoVarious laws, court rulings, and even provisions written into the contracts themselves as a result of earlier abuses by other franchises stop this kind of thing from happening to McD franchises. But make no mistake--this does happen to other types of franchises. These lawsuits simply don't make the news because they're not general-interest or (for HN) tech-interest events.
- KMag 13y ago(1) Local protectionism but also (2) Car dealerships need expensive inventory of illiquid assets and franchise licenses. If the franchise contracts aren't well written (perhaps collusion between manufacturers prevents competition over franchise rights), then a big auto company can maximize profits by selling franchise rights and then a couple years later looking at volumes of sales for which areas it makes sense to set up their own stores and undercut the franchise owners. The franchise owners need to amortize their franchise costs, but not so for the direct sales shops. The argument becomes that the historical implication has been that in the auto industry selling local monopoly franchise rights has implied no direct competition from the manufacturers. Perhaps a better law would be that no manufacturer with existing franchise owners in the state can have direct sales in the state.
- mortenjorck 13y agoPerhaps a better law would be that no manufacturer with existing franchise owners in the state can have direct sales in the state. As arbitrary a distinction as that may be, it honestly sounds like this would satisfy everyone involved.
- jrs235 13y agoExcept the manufacturers that don't want another manufacturer to able to sell in the state. Especially since that new manufacturer will be selling directly allowing their cars to be sold for less than if a franchise fee had to be amortized into every vehicle sold (in other words, they'll have lower overhead costs), which still affects the existing dealerships who won't be happy as they will be at a slight disadvantage.
- webmaven 13y agoBasically, a manufacturer that wanted to sell direct would have to buy out the dealerships first.
- AaronM 13y agoIts my understanding that dealerships maintain no inventory of vehicles, at least not new vehicles, on their books.
- jessedhillon 13y agoNPR's Planet Money did a great program on this topic, "Why Buying A Car Is So Awful" http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/12/171814201/episode-435-why-buying-a-car-is-so-awful http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/12/171814201/episode-...
- throw_away 13y agoIn addition to what the others have said in response, I've heard that car dealerships collect a fairly hefty chunk of local sales taxes due to the nature of the product they are selling, which may give them some leverage with local governments to keep things the way they are.
- spo81rty 13y agoThat would still happen when you license the car at the DMV. Even for cars purchased out of state.