5 ms·
The insurance companies are whining because the exchanges force them to actually compete. This will put strong negative pressure on their margins. The extra vol
by jjoonathan 13y ago
The insurance companies are whining because the exchanges force them to actually compete. This will put strong negative pressure on their margins. The extra volume won't come close to making up for their losses.
Before the exchanges and the standardized tiers of care, plans were very difficult for consumers to quantitatively compare. Most consumers didn't bother, so insurance companies were able to differentiate themselves with advertising and "fluff features" (easy) rather than by cutting costs and increasing efficiency (hard). Not only did consumers pay for the higher margins that came from fluff-differentiation, but they also never benefitted from competition over efficiency. The setup was good for insurance companies and bad for consumers. Now the party is over and the insurance companies are upset that their cash cow has been slaughtered.
Good riddance.
- fennecfoxen 13y agoBah. Say what you like about the old model, but you can't really call what the insurance companies have been mandated to do under the ACA "competition" -- you can barely call it insurance anymore.
- jjoonathan 13y agoWhy don't you think exchanges are competitive? I put forward a detailed argument about why I think they increase competition. I'd appreciate a response in kind. Also, why do you think "you can barely call it insurance anymore"? It used to be that insurance companies in the individual market were allowed to invent excuses to dump their expensive customers and then they were allowed to raise their prices if the customer wanted back in. Basically, the individual insurance market degraded into "pay the full price of any chronic condition you have." I wouldn't call that insurance, I'd call that pay-as-you-go-with-a-middleman. Now that they actually have to provide the "peace of mind" that they sell, I think the argument is much stronger for calling them insurance companies. So, basically, the opposite of what you said.
- fennecfoxen 13y agoYou seem to imply that insurance companies dumped people after they developed an expensive condition. But that's a load of FUD, as dumping a customer like that's been illegal for decades. Which isn't to say that you could get someone else to pay for your pre-existing conditions before. That's genuinely new. Anyway. There's no health insurance market anymore. There's a pre-paid healthcare services market which we call "insurance", with a nearly uniform price guaranteed to all (variance in prices regulated by the government), a very specific government-mandated bundle of services that it must provide, a government-mandated maximum profit margin, and a government mandate that the services be purchased. So if that's your picture of healthy "competition" in a market... well, I guess you're entitled to that opinion but then I kinda wonder what you must think about the rest of the tech startups that get discussed around here.
- DavidAdams 13y agoWhat used to happen routinely is that when an insurance customer developed an expensive condition a "rescission" team would do a detailed audit of their initial application and medical history, looking for a pretext to break the contract. So if they went to the doctor prior to enrolling and complained about back pain, but didn't disclose that in their application, if that back pain could in any way be connected to their later cancer diagnosis, the contract can be voided and the insurance company could drop the customer and not pay for their treatment.
- jjoonathan 13y agoAnd the recission teams were even paid on commission. Top prize to the person who figures out how to dump the lady with cancer, second prize to anyone who can figure out what clauses to add to the new contracts to catch people like her in the future! Also, don't forget the other tricks: shifting billing dates around, losing invoices in the mail, using the customer's income to calculate copays which would bankrupt them before they could afford expensive treatment... the list goes on. EDIT: this is why I said that the insurance companies had to find an excuse to drop people, rather than just drop people. The really obvious stuff tends to be illegal.
- joering2 13y agoInsurance companies are not whining; on the other hand media do on their behalf, but insurance companies basically wrote the law, so you won't see BlueCross or Athena CEO on the news anytime soon "whining" on the new law.
- jjoonathan 13y agoI disagree. Not about the fact that politicians and the media put words into the mouths of insurance companies for the purposes of political gain, but about you claim that "insurance companies basically wrote the law." I don't think they made off nearly as well as you think they did. Also, we wouldn't expect their CEOs to make much of a stink about this, at least not publicly (perhaps I should have said "hurting" instead of "whining"). We would expect them to be busy telling investors how they plan to best take advantage of the new rules. Because that's what they're paid to do. Any CEO who says they don't know how to do this is begging to be replaced. We'll be able to tell who was right in 3-4 years by comparing their margins (or another metric like administrative overhead) to what we see today in the individual insurance market. I would bet a sizable chunk of money that they will be much closer to the margins we see in the employer-provided insurance market today.
- DavidAdams 13y agoThe insurance companies were consulted and included while the law was being drafted (over decades, because remember a lot of the groundwork was laid by the Republicans during the Clinton Administration). But it's not all rosy for them. They accepted the downside of this approach to healthcare reform because they saw potential alternatives as being much worse. A single-payer system would put the lot of them out of business, so they were willing to take some lumps to ensure that they're part of the American healthcare system moving forward.