3 ms·
>In other words, contradictory beliefs imply anything and everything is true (and false). This is an odd result especially since anyone with an ounce of humilit
by eli_gottlieb 13y ago
>In other words, contradictory beliefs imply anything and everything is true (and false). This is an odd result especially since anyone with an ounce of humility will admit that there is a reasonably high chance that there is a contradiction in their beliefs or in the logical consequences of their beliefs.
Yeah, but we deal with this very simply: by using probability (conceived as a real-valued logic) instead of boolean logic, at which point any contradiction in our axioms gets us an "exception signal" of some probability somewhere going to 0.0 instead of an equal belief in all possible propositions.
Or we can use constructive logic instead of classical, in which case we'll be able to actually find a contradiction simply by looking for assumptions that lead to a proof for the proposition False.
- dpierce9 13y agoThere are definitely other ways to handle this same problem, I was just pointing out one counterintuitive conclusion of classical inference rules as one motivation for non-classical logics. And, since both of your examples also involve non-classical logics, I think we generally agree that there is motivation here (setting aside the viability of your solutions)