3 ms·
This made me think of an interesting way I have heard some people answer the question "if God is omnipotent, then can he create a rock so heavy he wouldn't be a
by gambiting 13y ago
This made me think of an interesting way I have heard some people answer the question "if God is omnipotent, then can he create a rock so heavy he wouldn't be able to lift it and then lift it? If yes, he is not omnipotent, if no, he is not omnipotent!" with a logical leap also hard to comprehend to western minds - he can do both, and that's why he is considered omnipotent. He doesn't need to follow human logic, hence the third option - creating a rock too heavy to lift and lifting it.
I am completely non-religious,but as a logical riddle it always fascinated me that there could be a "third" option.
- dj-wonk 13y agoThis isn't as hard as some people make it out to be. If God has to obey logic and/or other laws, then of course, there are some limitations to his power. Could a dictator decide to set up a Constitution and limit his own powers? Of course. Having absolute powers means having the ability to limit your future power.
- thyrsus 13y agoA rock too heavy to lift would be a rock inside the event horizon of a black hole, if one can stipulate that the rock still "exists". My own attitude toward paradoxes concerning God is that understanding is a gift - awesome in its comprehension of the universe from big bang to Planck length scale interactions. Nonetheless, the understanding given to us as finite beings will be incomplete and approximate. If we avoid every other end, dementia will eventually remove what little understanding we have. I hold that rejection of the gift of understanding - e.g., the six day materialist biblical interpretation - is a grave error. Nonetheless, I hold that entities (or sets of relations) exist for which I will never have a consistent or correct rational model - and that one of those is God. Other instances are my fellow humans, and even myself. It should go without saying, ignorance does not preclude fascination with, delight in, nor love for those beings.