5 ms·
I'm a little skeptical that a human can do a better job on these than a computer. I guess the computer doesn't know the drivers intent, so he needs to control t
by ars 13y ago
I'm a little skeptical that a human can do a better job on these than a computer. I guess the computer doesn't know the drivers intent, so he needs to control things that will change after his next action (speed up/down, etc).
But I wonder if instead of controlling the parameters directly, instead you switch to an intent based system where you tell the computer what you are going to do.
Makes me ponder about computerized auto racing - same kind of car, track, and rules - just with a computer at the wheel. Then even on a human race the car pretends it was driving and adjusts things based on what it would do with the assumption the human would do the same (or close enough).
- sliverstorm 13y agoIt really isn't about which can do a better job, robots or people. It's about which is more fun to watch. Computers racing computers is about as exciting as a round of Mario Kart with no human players. FIA regulates the race with this exact thing in mind.
- inportb 13y agoComputers racing computers is pretty exciting to some people. http://arewefastyet.com/ http://arewefastyet.com/ http://speed.pypy.org/ http://speed.pypy.org/ http://benchmarksgame.alioth.debian.org/ http://benchmarksgame.alioth.debian.org/
- sliverstorm 13y agoYes, of course there is a niche. But F1 targets a very broad audience.
- RogerL 13y agoThose don't generate profits that allow a budget, for example, of $470 million dollars (US), which was Ferrari's budget in 2013. No one, for any reasonable value of "no one", wants to watch computer racing. I'll leave it to others to quibble about the outliers.
- slightlycuban 13y ago(I'm not up to date on the 2014 season, so a more avid fan might show me up) While the driver may be making adjustments to road-condition or in response to immediate problems detected in the car, the biggest reason he is going to have to fiddle with one of those knobs is strategy. Shift the brake balance and you shift the tire wear, which might get you more time in certain corners in traffic, or might preserve a set of tires for an extra lap. The DRS is almost a no-brainer, but the KERS can require some finesse. Hit it into the turn, on the follow through, coming out of the straight? That depends on who you're up against, how his car performs compared to yours, and how you're looking on fuel & tires. Also, FIA banned traction and launch control a few years ago, specifically because they were worried the computer was doing too much driving. Actually, they were worried that the top teams (Ferrari, Mercedes, etc) would be able to build a traction control so sophisticated that the lesser-funded teams would not be competitive.
- joshu 13y agoMcLaren's traction control is unreal, though it doesn't feel great when it kicks in. The rotation you get when it grabs one corner with the brakes is kinda crazy, though. The MP4-12c's namesake, the MP4-12 had TWO brake pedals, which let the driver apply braking to just one rear wheel, was eventually banned.
- CHY872 13y agoKERS is all decided by the computer now!
- NamTaf 13y agoAs the sibling said, it's about pushing more responsibility back on the driver. You're absolutely right that a computer would do a better job for many of the functions. One example is that they removed traction control from the cars a few seasons ago. Why? Because it made it easier for the drivers to drive optimally, but in doing so reduced the entertainment and variability of how the race unfolds. By removing it, it gives more chances for the driver to screw up and for the race to change. It's more exciting for the spectator. It was broadly held by many fans some years ago that F1 was becoming too robotic and taking all the fun and variety out of it. The race depended more on the tech that the team could jam in to the car, and the driver was really just a glorified program to run the basic functions. By making driver skill a bigger slice of the 'what it takes to win' pie, it made it more exciting to follow as a fan.
- bobbles 13y agoDriverless F1 cars in a race... now that would be an interesting competition
- noir_lord 13y agoTo us. I'm not convinced that it would be everyone, the "problem" with F1 over the last few years is that the personality and style of the drivers has taken a backseat to the technology. I find the technology fascinating but many of the races boring.
- Kudos 13y agoYou'd be more interested in the outcome and post-mortem than watching it unfold live, aside from the initial novelty.
- jordan0day 13y agoF1 races already seem to have hardly any passes -- I have to imagine putting computers at the helm will just bring that total down to zero.
- mcguire 13y agoWelcome to NASCAR, friends!
- InclinedPlane 13y agoThey can't, computers do better. But excess use of computers has been against the rules in F1 for a while, in a variety of ways. A consequence of this is that what actually happens during a race is that the race team will read all the sensor readouts from the vehicle then they figure out what change needs to be made. But they can't just press a button and make the change remotely, that's against the rules, so instead they radio the driver and he makes the change. Whether this is actually a better way to go is a bit of an open question.
- jeremysmyth 13y agoWhen you've travelled half a kilometer in the time it takes the engineer to tell you what to do, it means his instructions must be at a much higher level and relatively glacial response time than the driving instincts that make a great driver. On the other hand, if remote changes were allowed, the team could adjust brake balance (or mechanical ERS harvesting and consequent friction) based on the corner entry speed, braking point, and the driver's foot pressure (i.e. whether he's perfect or not), at the speed of telemetry.
- jordan0day 13y agoFolks are working on it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxHcJTs2Sxk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxHcJTs2Sxk