5 ms·
I'm shocked, shocked that there is shitty software running in this Samsung establishment. When I saw the title, I had a strong suspicion that it wasn't about ma
by mikestew 13y ago
I'm shocked, shocked that there is shitty software running in this Samsung establishment. When I saw the title, I had a strong suspicion that it wasn't about making the camera do cool things, but the subject would be "how broken is Samsung's firmware?"
What is it with Samsung and software? I mean, they can crank out some decent hardware, but their software is consistently abysmal. I have a Note 3. Ignore the plasticy and cheesy (fake leather stitching? Really?) exterior, and it's a decent piece of kit. But the included software is consistently crap. I bought the Note for the stylus, but both S Note and Action Memo apps that are to be used with the stylus consistently lost data. I think they fixed it in a later update (haven't lost data lately), but it doesn't inspire confidence.
The prime example is Samsung's new Gear Fit. It just plain doesn't work as advertised, and it's due to unbelievably broken software. The only things that work reliably are the notifications and the pedometer. And though the pedometer works (if a bit inaccurately) the data reporting is broken. I mean so broken that if you want a historical listing of your steps each day, you'll have to write it down because the data reporting is grossly inaccurate. Everything else, including most exercise functionality, just doesn't work. I thought it would be fun (and please pardon the shameless plug) to see if I can post a new bug every day: http://gearfitbugs.tumblr.com http://gearfitbugs.tumblr.com (been slacking the last few days for lack of time).
Point is, how do they stay in business? Who buys one Samsung product and then turns around later to buy another one (okay, me, I guess)? For me, they don't get three strikes. Two hardware products with amateur-level software (with apologies to all amateur developers out there; your stuff is likely better than Samsung's) are the only chances Samsung will get with me. And if they think I'm letting one of their Internet-connected TVs (with mic and camera) in my house, they're delusional.
The Gear Fit brought to mind another question that I'll likely never get an answer to: how does this happen? Fine, you made some really bad dev hires. But don't you have a test team? Does the test team suck, or are they just ignored? What about project management? When the test team comes back and says, "the cycling function doesn't work. It will never record a whole workout without stopping mid-way.", does PM just say "ship it anyway"? Come ship date, you just take whatever is sitting at HEAD no matter what shape it's in, build it and call it the RTM build? I would seriously pay a week's wages to spend a week with their product team to get a look from the inside on how not to build software.
- throwaway851223 13y ago> Come ship date, you just take whatever is sitting at HEAD no matter what shape it's in, build it and call it the RTM build? You nailed it, as if you saw it with your own eyes. Kudos.
- adynatos 13y agonah, head changelist usually doesn't build
- throwaway851223 13y agoYup. In the course of development, head changelist builds about 50% of the time. As deadline approaches, this probability slowly increases, but never gets to 100%.
- smtddr 13y agoI just don't think that many people really care. I buy Samsung products and they generally work. I've had 2 Samsung TVs and I'm still using the discontinued Galaxy Player[1]. Samsung is my go-to brand because while their software isn't perfect, they sometimes have a quirkiness about them that makes 'em unique. I think having a camera with X server running on it is cool. I have no idea what I'd do with it but cool nonetheless. >> Come ship date, you just take whatever is sitting at HEAD no matter what shape it's in, build it and call it the RTM build? "Pixar films don't get finished, they just get released." --- http://www.lettersofnote.com/2010/06/pixar-films-dont-get-finished-they-just.html http://www.lettersofnote.com/2010/06/pixar-films-dont-get-fi... 1. http://www.samsung.com/ca/consumer/tv-video/media-players/media-players/YP-G70CW/XAC-spec http://www.samsung.com/ca/consumer/tv-video/media-players/me... ...why not just get a smartphone? Because whatever, that's why.
- privong 13y agoI wish they still made the galaxy player. I'd love to have an android device that was a smartphone in all senses except for the phone.
- 13y ago