15 ms·
I don't understand the overt, superficial purpose of H-1B visas. If you have a company that needs one, and a foreigner who qualifies for it, why would it not b
by logfromblammo 13y ago
I don't understand the overt, superficial purpose of H-1B visas. If you have a company that needs one, and a foreigner who qualifies for it, why would it not be better for the public in every possible circumstance to just grant that foreign person an unconditional work visa and automatically enroll them for consideration for permanent residency?
And then I put my foil hat on, and the voices tell me that the H-1B program must not be for the benefit of the public, and that both the American workers and the foreigners with visas are being exploited for the benefit of the corporate sponsors.
The only benefit I see here to essentially doubling the number of available guest workers under H-1B is that the affected spouses are free to change employers and to quit from unsuitable employment without being deported. That makes them better off than the person that actually has the sponsorship!
- refurb 13y agoThe reason for the temporary nature of H1-Bs is that it's an attempt to provide a responsive immigration policy. Just because you can't find a US citizen to fill a role now, doesn't mean that 10 years from now you won't be. If 10 years from now a pool of qualified US workers becomes available, the H1-B approval would need to be repeated, the labor certification would fail and the immigrant would not be allowed to fill the role. I'm certainly not saying it's the best way to handle it, but that's the logic behind the current rules.
- logfromblammo 13y agoIf you make the worker a citizen, you can be absolutely certain that a citizen can fill the role, both now and ten years in the future. Otherwise, you are finding a different person to fill the role in ten years, and that person will be competing with someone in a foreign country that has 10 more years of experience.
- refurb 13y agoAnd if you make the worker a citizen and the industry crashes, you've got another person on social assistance. If they are on a non-immigrant visa, you send them home.
- shas3 13y agoForeign nonimmigrant workers should be as eligible for social assistance as anyone else. H1B workers pay almost exactly the same federal, state, and local taxes as citizens and permanent residents. In general, restrictive visa rules are a form of protectionism, where the government arbitrarily assigns financial benefits and unequal opportunities in favor of citizens. [edit: wrong usage of 'immigrants', changed to 'nonimmigrant']
- refurb 13y agoNon-immigrant workers do pay the same taxes as citizens, however, they don't pay them over the same time period. If a citizen starts working at 18, gets laid off at 32 and doesn't find another job until 34, that's much cheaper than a non-immigrant who comes to the US at 32 and ending up on unemployment at 34 for 2 years before going back home.
- prodigal_erik 13y agoOver a billion people out there live on less than 2 USD/day. Protectionism is the only force sparing us from an existence like that. Dividing the world's resources fairly would result in universal grinding poverty rather than luxuries like the Internet.
- logfromblammo 13y agoThat's 2 non sequiturs in three sentences. The reason why people live in grinding poverty is because they are, for a stunningly wide variety of reasons, unable to accumulate capital and bring their own resources to market. If you divide resources fairly today, they will be back to poverty tomorrow, because the very same people will take the distributed resources away from them that currently take their savings opportunities. Besides that, the flip side of your argument is that protectionism is the only force keeping poor people from becoming rich. Economics is not a zero-sum game. It is far more complex than you portray.
- prodigal_erik 13y ago