4 ms·
Let's wait and see how it will actually work. The guys who designed Space Shuttle also expected much more reusability than what they managed to achieve. There a
by acqq 13y ago
Let's wait and see how it will actually work. The guys who designed Space Shuttle also expected much more reusability than what they managed to achieve. There are serious physical limits that you just can't be even aware of until you actually try.
- aleyan 13y agoThat makes sense. There is also a question of will though. IANARS (I am not a rocket scientist), but it seems to me a lot of political investment behind rockets in USA and USSR was military in origin. This meant the rockets and rocket engines they spent most effort on was for single delivery of a warhead with no chance of reuse. Civilian rocketry was just a byproduct of efforts to deliver the bomb. We see this with Russian commercial satellite launches using repurposed ICBMs. If military didn't care about the reuse, the civilian programs would have had to work on it on their own. I believe that with enough will and advances in technology, engineering problems for reusable rocket engines could be overcome.
- simonh 13y agoYep, the whole industry, including payload manufacturing and operational economics, is geared around super-high launch costs. That means you spare no expense making sure your payload is absolutely perfect. High costs of launch breed high costs for payload design and manufacture, which means you need to guarantee a high chance of getting your precious payload to orbit, which means you want a pristine rocket to carry it for the best chance of a successful launch. It's a vicious cycle, driving up quality requirements and costs at every point in the cycle. SpaceX is intending to break that cycle. If launch costs are low, then you can afford to put cheap payloads into orbit. If the payload fails, just launch another one. If the best chance of a successful launch matters a lot to you, pay a premium to launch on a virgin booster. However re-usability of the first stage is only going to get them so far. If half the total cost of a launch (pure guess) is in the booster hardware, and they get just 10 launches out of each one, then the total cost per launch will be cut to close to half of what it is now. That's great, amazing even, but it's not 10x cheaper and certainly not 100x. To get down even close to 10x cheaper they need to recover the second stage as well.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoA huge amount of investment in rocketry in the US was very much civilian. Easily a quarter of a trillion dollars, and that's excluding Apollo. However, that money was not well spent. I could go into the topic in depth but suffice it to say that politics and bureaucracy have had a stranglehold on NASA manned spaceflight and launch vehicle development since the beginning, and that has had a very negative impact on progress and capabilities. In contrast, unmanned spaceflight at NASA has been, comparatively, much better managed. And there you see a much clearer and sharper continual increase in capabilities, ambition, missions, and so on over time. The missions that would have been acceptable in the 1970s (planetary flybys, for example) would today not return enough science to be justified. Today we have multi-year rover missions on Mars, and we have spacecraft which rendezvous and orbit multiple asteroids using ion engines. Meanwhile, in manned spaceflight we haven't been out of Earth orbit since the early '70s.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoThe Space Shuttle is an enormously complicated system. The Orbiter itself is a marriage of a crew transfer spacecraft, a space station, a cargo tug, a cargo carrier, and a goddamned airplane. Worse yet, it used one of the most finicky propellants around, LOX/LH2. Then you shoehorn that beast into a weirdly designed partially expendable heavy lift launcher with SRBs and a drop tank and it's no wonder you end up with a system that is difficult to operate inexpensively. Meanwhile, the Falcon 9 stage is primarily just engines, tanks, and frame, with a sprinkling of avionics and RCS plus landing legs for the reusable version. The idea that a system so monstrously simple in comparison to the Shuttle could possibly have the same levels of difficulty of reusability is either extraordinarily naive or propaganda.
- acqq 13y agoNo, it's not propaganda, if you'd care to search you'd find enough material yourself. They first planned to reuse the booster engines and just produce new tanks. They discovered that the engines weren't reusable as much as they hoped only once they made actual launches. The rocket engines function a bit differently than the jet engines, all the problems are bigger by the order of magnitude. The engines have to sustain immense temperature extremes, which in turn change the characteristics of the parts. What's usable on the first launch can be just a trash the next time. Until you have enough launches, you just don't know how reusable equipment you have.
- dba7dba 13y agoTrue. But falcon 9 is far less complicated than shuttle so the chance of having more reusable equipment should be higher.
- acqq 13y agoI'm giving the example not of the whole Shuttle (complex) but just the booster engines for Shuttle (also simple). Designed to be very reusable, discovered not to be only after the real launches. That's how it works. Before you have the actual launch statistics, you can appear much smarter than you are actually. Everything is easy as long as it's just a theory. To compare, let's see what SpaceX is actually doing: The last, second attempt to recover a booster of Falcon 9 was: http://aviationweek.com/space/spacex-plans-multiple-reusable-booster-tests http://aviationweek.com/space/spacex-plans-multiple-reusable... "While SpaceX remains coy about the exact fate of the modified Falcon 9 first stage, the overall results appear to be encouraging despite the apparent breakup of the booster after it landed in heavy seas." Previous attempt: "The latest flight test follows an unsuccessful recovery attempt on Sept. 29, 2013, when the first upgraded Falcon 9 v1.1 was launched from Vandenberg AFB, Calif. Although three of its nine Merlin 1D engines fired to slow the initial descent ahead of a single engine firing for final braking, the vehicle’s spinning motion could not be controlled. As a result of aerodynamic torque, the fuel centrifuged inside the tank, flaming out the engine and sending the stage crashing into the sea."
- mikeash 13y agoThe Space Shuttle was a political football whose design was dictated by the whims of Congress and the meddling of the military first, and by engineering second. The Shuttle was required to be reusable as a political goal. However, it was not given the funding it needed to actually accomplish it in any reasonable fashion. The Air Force put some tough requirements on it, such as the requirement for enough cross-range capability when landing to be able to launch into a polar orbit from Vandenberg, deploy a satellite, and land back one orbit later. This is purely a wartime requirement. No peacetime mission needs this. This required much bigger wings (and thus much more weight), even though the Shuttle never once launched out of Vandenberg, let alone on one of these crazy single-orbit missions. Politics screwed up other stuff too. The solid rocket boosters, for example, were manufactured on the other side of the country, largely because of Congressional pork. The long and difficult transport process required the boosters to be built segmented, and that design directly lead to the loss oF Challenger. Similarly, budget constraints dictated the cheaper SRB-plus-external-tank design rather than a more sophisticated and more reusable (and more expensive) reusable booster. This design directly lead to the loss of Columbia. The net result was that the Shuttle had a very narrow engineering margin. The SSMEs are engineering marvels in terms of how light they are and how much power they put out. But putting out a lot of power for little weight is a really bad plan for something you want to reuse. Reusability means robustness, and robustness means extra weight and less power. The Shuttle is what you get when you say, "How much will it cost for a reusable launch system? $10 billion? Too much, we'll give you $5 billion." (Numbers in the ballpark but mostly made up for illustration.) On the other hand, the Falcon 9R is what you get when a for-profit space launch company wants to make more money. It's not a prestige project, it's not a political project, it's not a military project dictated by thoughts of all-out war with the USSR, it's not subject to Presidential grandstanding or Congressional pork. It's just a bunch of smart people thinking of ways to save their customers money and turn a better profit while doing it. The Shuttle was an extremely ambitious design that did everything differently. Ultimately, everything was too ambitious to be reusable. Falcon 9R, on the other hand, is deeply unambitious. The rocket is a pretty standard design. They don't even try to use liquid hydrogen for any stage, even though it's theoretically more efficient, instead favoring easier-to-handle kerosene. Their rocket engines are high performance but not on the bleeding edge. And when they decided to go for reusability, instead of building a whole new system with wings and ceramic tiles and all sorts of other extreme innovations, they just said, let's slap some legs on the first stage and give it some extra fuel. It's a completely different approach that pretty much only shares the word "reusable". I don't think the Shuttle really has many lessons to offer when evaluating the potential of Falcon 9R.