2 ms·
> This is too US-centric, especially as it implies that drone proliferation will slow down if the US stops its own development. This is nonsense. Where do you
by Jtsummers 13y ago
> This is too US-centric, especially as it implies that drone proliferation will slow down if the US stops its own development. This is nonsense.
Where do you get that from?
Some quotes from the article:
Virtually every country on Earth will be able to build or
acquire drones capable of firing missiles within the next ten
years. Armed aerial drones will be used for targeted killings,
terrorism and the government suppression of civil
unrest. What’s worse, say experts, it’s too late for the United
States to do anything about it.
“Once countries like China start exporting these, they’re going
to be everywhere really quickly. Within the next 10 years,
every country will have these,” Noel Sharkey, a robotics and
artificial intelligence professor from the University of
Sheffield, told Defense One.
Singer cautions that while the U.S. may be trying to wean
itself off of armed UAV technology, many more countries are
quickly becoming hooked.
So, what option does that leave U.S. policy makers wanting to
govern the spread of this technology? Virtually none, say
experts. “You’re too late,” said Sharkey, matter-of-factly.
The rest of your post, other than the comments on earlier-than-US use of drones, is a rehash of the various points in the article.
- _djo_ 13y agoIt's underscored by one of the quotes used to end the piece off: Less impressed, Sharkey said the U.S. still has time to rethink its drone future. “Don’t go to the next step. Don’t make them fully autonomous. That will proliferate just as quickly and then you are really going to be sunk.” And the opening premise of the article is not only that armed UAV technology is spreading, but that the reader should somehow be concerned that the US is unable to stop it. It speaks about what options are available to US policy makers to govern the spread of the technology, correctly answering 'none' but not once mentioning that the US never had any ability to govern the spread of UAV technology. Especially because it was not the originator of it. The rest of the article is ok, particularly the quotes attributed to Singer (an excellent writer on the subject), Sam Brennan and Mary Commings and the maps showing which countries are using or developing armed and unarmed UAVs. I just feel it's let down by the editorial slant and US-centric focus.