3 ms·
I really like how Ruth's oncologist told her the truth. I don't want to be lied to by any doctor, but especially not about cancer.
by danieltillett 13y ago
I really like how Ruth's oncologist told her the truth. I don't want to be lied to by any doctor, but especially not about cancer.
- scobar 13y agoIn my experience, the "lying" was not directly that, nor was it even omission. It was simply providing small, though often false, hopes very similar to what her oncologist did toward the end of the story telling her to hold off on chemo for one more day. It's a delicate balance the oncologists must deal with as depression is a very real issue, and sometimes their goal is quality of life until the end.
- danieltillett 13y agoThis is not really the doctors choice to make. I guess if the patient does not request the full truth then there might be some justification for lying if they think it will help the patient, but if a patient asks direct to be told everything then they should be told. I certainly want to be told the full truth at all times even if it is bad news.
- scobar 13y agoI agree that the doctor should be honest and clear about the diagnosis. The treatment options, their potential effectiveness, and the rate of decline due to the illness varies enough that it's very difficult for the doctor to offer more than percentages and statistics rather than the definitive answers most patients desire.
- danieltillett 13y agoI wish I could get percentages or statistics out of the doctors I have had to deal with. Whenever I have asked direct questions I get handwaving and I am spoken to like I am an idiot.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoI can sympathize with a doctor who's told the whole truth, then seen people spiral off into depression, or get a divorce, or run off to Buenos Aires and join a maraca band. Its hard to watch patients do things the doctor may think are sad or wrong or disruptive. If they were a life coach, or a minister, or a spouse, then sure they should be managing hope, keeping the patient positive, working to keep the family functioning. But they're not any of those things. Its not their responsibility nor right to decide how a patient should react, or to manipulate the patient to get a reaction they approve of. Its their responsibility to diagnose, treat and inform. Anything else is hubris. If I'm going to die soon, its my right to make a crappy decision to run off with a prostitute and get blind drunk. Or stay with my family in hospice and pray. Or whatever. My right. No one elses.
- saraid216 13y agoThis is completely off-topic, but: I was at a talk last week where a politician (local school board guy) explained his engagement with the public thusly: We're trustees. We tell you what needs to be done; we tell you how much money it's going to take; we let you make the decision. It feels exactly like how the doctor went about explaining their options. And I like it.
- danieltillett 13y agoUnfortunately this is not how most politicians operate. Doctors are not gods. They are experts we consult for advice on the best way to solve a problem. If I ask an architect how I should go about building a house I expect to be told the truth - I don't want to find out halfway through a build that the idea I suggested means the house will now cost three time more than the available budget. Sometime there are no good solutions (like in the story), but even in this case the patient should be told the truth if they want to know it.
- dkrich 13y agoI was thinking this, too. It's hard to say for sure what I'd want in that situation but I think sincerity helps because eventually when good news comes it makes it much more believable than coming from somebody who never gives you bad news.