5 ms·
I do have a bit of a problem with it. Suppose if rather than a truck it were a giant scarecrow with cameras, placed facing the house of people suspected of hav
by grandalf 17y ago
I do have a bit of a problem with it.
Suppose if rather than a truck it were a giant scarecrow with cameras, placed facing the house of people suspected of having committed a crime.
Is the average person allowed to own a vehicle with cameras and park it outside the home of someone they don't like?
It seems like blatant harassment.
- tedunangst 17y ago"Is the average person allowed to own a vehicle with cameras and park it outside the home of someone they don't like?" Yes.
- grandalf 17y agoI know parking there is legal, but I suspect if the vehicle had cameras trained on the house it would be considered harassment.
- sokoloff 17y agoWhile I don't necessarily condone it, I don't see how parking in a public place taking camera pictures of things in plain public view would actually be harassment. Google street view mapping of public roads and views accessible from same is perfectly legal, right? (and perfectly reasonable, right?) Why would this not be legal?
- electromagnetic 17y agoTaking pictures wouldn't be illegal from a public place, similar to google's street view. Taking multiple pictures over a prolonged time could likely fall under harassment laws, depending on your state or country. Videoing someone else's property, if done on purpose, is illegal, unless you have a valid reason for doing so. If your neighbour has 'violated the peace', IE noise disturbance (that you called the cops for) or something else but has been warned but not charged, then you can video tape someone else's property. If they're on the sexual offenders list or have a suspended sentence, or have been convicted of any crime that hasn't expired from their record. For example, your neighbour could have shoplifted, which IIRC stays on their record for 5-10 years after their punishment is served, you can legally record them (if you suspect them of other illegal activity, not because you're a pervert) until this time is spent. If you're recording them after this has expired, you're likely breaking the law and you're 100% open to a civil suit. However, if you have a neighbour you feel is dodgy, simply place a CCTV on your property to monitor a part of your property so it accidentally catches the other persons property (this has been proven legal in the UK, USA, CA, NZ and Australia, AFAIK). If you think your neighbour is doing something illegal in their back yard, but can't prove it, well you can legally video tape your back yard with a wide angle lens. Audio recording someone else's conversation is definitely illegal; conversations are considered private, unless you're included in them. Public property is a different matter, but anywhere on private property is a crime, even if it is your private property, if the conversation doesn't include you it's still a crime. Basically, if what you're photographing, and to some extent video taping and even less audio taping, what you could see or hear from the road if you stood there for 8 hours then that's legal. If you're purposely pointing the camera through windows, or any audio recording of their property, then you're getting yourself in a dangerous position. If your neighbour shouts and screams and can be heard on your property, that's legal to record. Laws vary between countries, but generally if there's laws to protect you from the police doing said action, you definitely shouldn't be doing it. Also be careful, it can be illegal to photograph someone without their express permission, even on public property. I know a photographer got fined $1,000 here in Canada for photographing a girl in a bikini without asking. She told him to delete the photograph, he didn't. He was fined $1,000 by the police, and I believe she dropped civil action against him due to the police record, I think he was liable up to $25,000 in the small claims court she was taking him through. So, personally, I wouldn't photograph something I don't own, or that no one owns. There's no sense putting yourself at risk for cash. In this case, if the cops are just sat there in a surveillance van, not surveillancing anyone then it's legal. If they put it on a street with a known high crime rate, it's okay. If they put it on your street because of you, that's harassment.
- shard 17y agoIn the US at least, photography on public property does not require the permission of the subject, otherwise photography in crowded tourist spots would be well nigh impossible. There are of course exceptions, such as when the subject expects privacy (even in public, upskirts are no good), when you are making a profit from your photographs (which will then require model releases), or when "national security" is involved. (ref http://www.krages.com/phoright.htm http://www.krages.com/phoright.htm ) In the UK it is approximately the same, with the addition that the subject may not be harassed (defined as behavior that causes alarm or distress over multiple incidents) (ref http://www.sirimo.co.uk/2009/05/14/uk-photographers-rights-v2/ http://www.sirimo.co.uk/2009/05/14/uk-photographers-rights-v... ) I've found the relevant laws regarding photography in Canada (http://ambientlight.ca/laws.php http://ambientlight.ca/laws.php), and it seems to follow the US and UK in general. Therefore I think there are unspecified extenuating circumstances in the case of the photographer that got fined $1000. Ever since 9/11 there has been increasing scaremongering regarding people using "professional" looking cameras, which is an erosion of rights with no real benefits. I wouldn't photograph something I don't own, or that no one owns This would restrict you to photography only within your house, with all the shades drawn. Maybe even with the TV off.
- electromagnetic 17y ago"I wouldn't photograph something I don't own, or that no one owns This would restrict you to photography only within your house, with all the shades drawn. Maybe even with the TV off." I actually mistyped that sentence, sorry. What I meant was: I would only photograph something I own, or that no one owns. I don't know how I messed that sentence up, I guess my brain flat-lined for a minute.
- shard 17y agoThat doesn't make it much better. You still can't take photos in public where there are strangers, cars, or non-governmental buildings present. So pretty much it's photos inside your house, landscapes, and clouds.
- gojomo 17y agoThat depends a lot on local laws an mores; reaction to Google Street View photos has been been far more negative in some jurisdictions than the US. Also, to the extent focused surveillance reveals anything of interest -- times of comings and goings; activity behind windows; children's play activities -- I suspect most US jurisdictions would have a problem with 24-hour video surveillance of property you don't own.
- blhack 17y agoYou may wish to visit this website: http://maps.google.com http://maps.google.com. Pick a location, then hit "street view".
- grandalf 17y agofunny,... but it just snaps a single picture, and in no way monitors what is going on at street level.
- brandon272 17y agoIs there a big difference, from a legal perspective?
- Semiapies 17y agoYou might want to educate yourself about harassment law.
- chrischen 17y agoYea but the people were being harassed by the illegal activity first. Also the truck was an eyesore for criminals. normal people would actually like it if cops were nearby preventin' crime.
- grandalf 17y agoNormal people always imagine that there is no way they would ever be considered criminal enough to themselves warrant such treatment... It sounds like this is your view.
- chrischen 17y agoWhat treatment? It's a scarecrow, not a killer scarecrow. Yes it's my view in that I am not a drug dealer, it is preferable for me to have this in front of my house (granted there is a drug dealing/violent illegal activity in my neighborhood) to warrant it.
- grandalf 17y agoIf you trust law enforcement officials to do this, then why not require far more detailed surveillance as a matter of course, in the name of preventing criminality?
- chrischen 17y agoWhy would I want far more surveillance? I want what's enough to get those damn drug dealers out of my yard! Is that too much to ask without slipping off your slope!?! First of all that truck was not meant as surveillance. You'll have read in the article that they used the cameras mainly as a deterrent. These cops are just trying to help. Why make it seem like they're trying to start the next totalitarian regime? So I ask you, is there anything explicitly wrong about their limited use of cameras and a police van, without going into what it could lead to?
- grandalf 17y ago