3 ms·
“You’re white, and your built-in privilege makes it difficult for you to see how affirmative action merely levels the playing field.” THESE ARE NOT V
by michaelt 13y ago
“You’re white, and your built-in privilege makes it
difficult for you to see how affirmative action merely
levels the playing field.”
THESE ARE NOT VALID ARGUMENTS.
Seems to me whether low-quality argument A trumps other argument B depends on whether B is also a low-quality argument.
I wouldn't take an argument about privilege over the results of high quality scientific trials. But against anecdotal evidence from someone anonymous on the internet? I'll consider it.
For example, if argument A is "I've never seen a black person having trouble hailing a cab", I'd be relatively more convinced by argument B, "That's because you're a rich white guy, what would you know about getting a cab when you're black?"
On the other hand, if argument A is "These peer-reviewed scientific studies, which sent black and white researchers to hail cabs in different parts of the city, and controlled for day, time, age and dress showed that problems getting a cab are independent of race" and I would be relatively less convinced by argument B.
(For what it's worth, when I leave the opera or ballet, no-one has any problem getting a cab, be they black or white, male or female)
- bmmayer1 13y agoYou make a good point, which is that many arguments devolve into a plethora of logical fallacies anyway, and then it becomes a battle over whose logical fallacy is "better." Don't know about you, but I've long since stopped bothering to participate in these...it's not really worth it.
- sharemywin 13y agoAs sad as it is seems like most political debates are a "plethora of logical fallacies"?