4 ms·
When you're not cherry-picking, you're distorting the numbers. For one thing, you're taking numbers starting in 2003 and ending in 2009. Is that two years? N
by notacoward 13y ago
When you're not cherry-picking, you're distorting the numbers. For one thing, you're taking numbers starting in 2003 and ending in 2009. Is that two years? No, and 92800 is not twice 49000 either. Also, the proper comparison is not to 1000 small companies but to small companies with an aggregate head count equal to the starting 49000. If you look at the census figures[1] the biggest numbers by far are for non-employing firms (i.e. only owners) or firms with only 1-4 employees. So we're talking about more like 10000 companies at least, and yes, those are very likely to generate at least 43800 new jobs over six years even if most fail. According to the Small Business Administration[2], small businesses have accounted for 66% of net new jobs since the 1970s. Net, so that's even including those that failed. If fewer small businesses are starting, that 66% starts going down, and it doesn't take long before the net for the whole economy goes negative.
Fewer small businesses is a bad thing, to such an obviously huge degree that I'm amazed I even have to explain it - especially here. Really, all you "skeptics" need to do is educate yourselves.
[1] https://www.census.gov/econ/smallbus.html https://www.census.gov/econ/smallbus.html
[2] http://www.sba.gov/content/small-business-trends http://www.sba.gov/content/small-business-trends
- wil421 13y agoYou are arguing for small business but the census links are mainly showing people who are self employed and have no employees besides themselves. How can a one person company grow the economy and provide jobs?
- dragontamer 13y agoCase in point: the "self-employeed company". I'm sure you're all familiar with some company out there that uses "Independent Contractors" (various insurance companies... most door-to-door jobs, a lot of sales representatives...) Do note, independent contractors are considered 1-man companies. Surely, these are NOT "small businesses", but simply employees whose employer is too lazy to get them federal benefits. Again, large companies who are taking advantage of the tax code... which pads the small business numbers. (In this case, they take advantage of the fact that they don't have to pay payroll taxes on Independent Contractors). Hedge Fund managers also come in from this side. They can be independent contractors that are responsible for millions of dollars. IIRC, there were some regulations here that benefit the creation of "new independent companies"... usually employing only one person.
- hga 13y agoIn order for the first set of "1-man companies" to pass IRS muster, as a rule they've got to have a set of characteristics like a degree of autonomy. The ones you listed sound like they could pass muster; compare to "typical" computer programmers like many on this site who work at one location, doing tasks directed by a manager, etc., and who don't (as of 1986-7). If the company doesn't want to make them regular employees, they have to go through a body shop. else the IRS may realize the game, and require the company to pay back W2 type taxes, interest and penalties, never-mind that the individuals have been playing their FICA taxes (both "shares") etc. I'm not sure this is a big problem. I'm particularly unsure what the problem would be with "hedge fund managers" (aside from our required Two Minute Hate). What major expenses do they have that can make a noticeable dent in their outsized incomes? Surely they're sufficiently big fish they don't get away with cheating on the FICA taxes? Etc. (I say this as the son of a serial small businessman, who's watched him thread the needle of the IRS's requirements for much of his life.)
- dragontamer 13y agoThe door-to-door sales jobs I've seen are right on the edge. They may expect you to come in at certain times for "unpaied team meetings", there is an expectation to arrive at "nonmandatory training", etc. etc. Words that are used to prove to the IRS that they are running "independent contractors" while barely skidding the line. Does this look like an Independent Contracting gig to you? http://vectormarketing.com/ http://vectormarketing.com/ Anyway, the important bit is that "small businesses" are poorly classified in the USA. A lot of one-man shops are basically poorly-treated employees, skirting the law so that they can ignore certain taxes. Yes, there has been growth in "small businesses", but unless we get more data, there is no way to tell if small businesses are actually growing, or if companies are simply shedding employees for independent contractors to avoid payroll taxes.
- wil421 13y agoInteresting, lets go back to the original subject of the article. Do you think these small companies the article said are failing are actually "companies" in the traditional sense or one man operations combined with "tax saving" contractors? It seems we may need more data to draw conclusions.
- dragontamer 13y agoI think we all can agree that "true small businesses" are a good thing. What I'm worried about are all of the "fake small businesses" who are taking advantage of tax benefits. http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/tax-policy/tax-analysis/Documents/OTA-T2011-04-Small-Business-Methodology-Aug-8-2011.pdf http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/tax-policy/tax-analy... The current methodologies for determining "small businesses" are inadequate. The truth of the matter is, large companies (like Coke) are increasingly owning subsidiary companies which technically count as a Small Business. The most audacious of which, are Hedge Funds, which due to their small number of employees... are considered small businesses. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/21/small-business-tax-cut-eric-cantor_n_1371147.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/21/small-business-tax-... Do you really want to know why "small businesses" are making jobs? Because large companies are reorganizing themselves as a bunch of small companies to take advantage of tax benefits. I'm talking about Green Mountain Coffee, Honest Tea, and other subsidiaries of Coca-Cola which count as small businesses, despite being fully owned by larger businesses. Consider "Honest Tea", which was 40% owned by Coke since its inception. With its paltry 112 employees, it is considered a small business by the American Tax Code. But lets be frank here. Now that "Honest Tea" is 100% owned by Coca-cola, it is nowhere near a small business. When a large company reorganizes itself so that 1 million of its jobs are moved into subsidiary companies... that isn't "Small Businesses making jobs", that's "Large Businesses taking advantage of dumb tax code". And as long as the "Small Business Myth" remains, you can expect "large business" to reorganize themselves to take advantage of tax benefits.