4 ms·
Well, it's not like my card is hooked up to the internet for everybody to try and log in. PIN isn't particularly vulnerable to brute force anyway, as number of
by PeterisP 13y ago
Well, it's not like my card is hooked up to the internet for everybody to try and log in.
PIN isn't particularly vulnerable to brute force anyway, as number of failed authorisation attempts is strictly limited to something like 3, and a fraudster has to risk capture by being physically present at each attempt or 'trying out' a stolen card, and having their face recorded on cameras.
I haven't seen any advantages for using 6-digit or larger "passwords" for that particular scenario. The largest practical security benefit seems to come from enforcing random PINs and not allowing to choose - since the banks that allow to choose are vulnerable to "dictionary attacks" of trying the user's birthday (obvious from other stuff in a stolen wallet) and stuff like 1234.
Now, checking "signature" instead of chip&pin, now that's an example of blind trust.
- penguat 13y agoNo need to be physically present anywhere except where the card is, and as for cameras, I see none on a PINSentry: https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=pinsentry&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=pMRoU_-TPMW4O4elgdAF&ved=0CAgQ_AUoAQ&biw=1858&bih=995 https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=pinsentry&source=lnms&tbm=...
- praptak 13y ago> Now, checking "signature" instead of chip&pin, now that's an example of blind trust. If even. I cannot find the original report, but there was a guy who tried all kinds of weird signatures including "I STOLE THIS CARD" and it only took purchasing 3 most expensive TVs and signing "NOT AUTHORIZED" for someone to question him. Unoriginal report: http://www.getrichslowly.org/blog/2006/07/29/the-credit-card-prank-crazy-signatures/ http://www.getrichslowly.org/blog/2006/07/29/the-credit-card...
- swimfar 13y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20130120184305/http://www.zug.com/pranks/credit_card/ https://web.archive.org/web/20130120184305/http://www.zug.co...
- danpalmer 13y agoInterestingly, the signature could be argued to be better in some cases: Under British law, a forged signature is never your fault, and the bank/merchant/card processor are liable (I can't remember exactly which, I think it depends). One of the reason that card issuers were so keen to switch to Chip&PIN/EMV is that the liability was turned over to the user. As they thought EMV was "unhackable", always a dangerous thought, it was always assumed that the user had told someone their PIN. It wasn't until relatively recently that the Cambridge University security research group showed that it was crackable, and the banks/etc started taking liability in some cases again.
- lostcolony 13y agoIt's better for the user when it comes to challenging a fraudulent purchase, but in terms of security, it's worse. That was the point.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 13y agoThere is no such thing as just "security". If the expected loss of funds for the user is lower, it is more secure - for the user.
- Nursie 13y agoActually that's subjective. If the overall fraud is lower then (potentially, I'm sure this doesn't actually happen) fees, charges, interest rates etc could be lower for all users, therefore they would benefit from security that lowered the overall cost of fraud and the overall number of incidences of fraud, even if individuals that directly experience fraud are worse off.
- dragonwriter 13y agoYes, but "security" isn't "overall cost", its about risk. I am more secure, even if my expected cost is higher, if I don't directly bear any risk of unconsented loss even if the overall incidence of fraud is higher and I am paying a distributed share of those costs.
- mikecb 13y agoIt was John Hargrave from zug.com, but I think zug is no longer with us.
- heldtogether 13y agoI was once refused a consumer credit application for a kitchen appliance because I'd forgotten to sign the back of my credit card. I had a passport and a photo driving license on me at the time but because there wasn't a signature they "couldn't be sure" it was me so they refused to process the application. I signed it in front of them (which matched my passport signature BTW) but was politely declined as they'd seen the card unsigned. Another example of security policy getting in the way of actual security.
- dak1 13y agoI had a slightly similar experience: I forgot to sign the back of my card, but the person just asked me to sign it and then made sure it matched my signature on the receipt.
- brohee 13y agoYou could have stolen the card of an homonym, so it kind of make sense. Printing a photo of the owner on credit cards would go a very long way and isn't too expensive, but this is a very high inertia industry.