3 ms·
tl;dr Sweden has 3 road deaths per 100,000 capita while Eurozone has 5.5 and USA 11. This is because Sweden build their roads with safety first (Lower speed l
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
tl;dr
Sweden has 3 road deaths per 100,000 capita while Eurozone has 5.5 and USA 11. This is because Sweden build their roads with safety first (Lower speed limits, better physical seperation of pedestrians and care).
But ... Deaths per capita is a broad statistic. What about broken down by urban and non urban areas? Pedestrian v cycle v motorised deaths. In the end what is the null value for deaths per capita comparisons? Is 3/100,000 and 5.5 actually statistically significant?
As for the comments on thread that say "yet another swedes do it all better than us article" - well In my view scandanavian and Dutch politics all have a much less emotional more "strict mother" approach to many political debates - road safety is just one such. And we know better decisions about hard subjects are made with emotion safely caged.
- 001sky 13y agoDeaths per road mile would be a more interesting statistic.
- Crito 13y agoI suspect that extremely long but relatively untraveled roads would throw that statistic off. A disused 200 mile long country road across North Dakota would probably easily offset high pedestrian deaths across a few blocks in a city. Sure, you're less likely to die on it.. but you're also less likely to be on it in the first place. Working in road usage could possibly correct this.
- craigvn 13y agoIn Australia we are often told country roads are the most dangerous. Drivers are less likely to concentrate, easily fall asleep at the wheel and speed. And trees are not very forgiving when you drive into one.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jcampbell1 13y agoFrom: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-related_death_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-re... Deaths per terameter driven. Sweden 3.2 Norway 3.5 UK 3.6 .... USA 8.5 .... UAE 310
- 001sky 13y agoThe data for deaths by US state is non-uniform: State Traffic Deaths (Per 100,000 Population) ________________ Wyoming 27.48 Mississippi 21.58 Arkansas 19.27 Montana 19.07 Alabama 18.01 Oklahoma 17.76 Kentucky 17.49 South Carolina 17.47 Wheras as in highly urbanized states: ___________________________ California 7.27 Illinois 7.22 Washington 6.79 New Jersey 6.32 Rhode Island 6.27 New York 6.19 Massachusetts 4.79 http://vehicle-fatalities.findthedata.org/ http://vehicle-fatalities.findthedata.org/
- tormeh 13y agoWhile I don't really agree with everything you said, I I have to say that Scandinavia, The Netherlands, Switzerland and Singapore are the best governed places on earth. I have no idea why the rest of the world don't just copy us. If this sounds like arrogance, then you are right, but it has pretty solid foundations.
- fleitz 13y agoMeh. There's really not that much difference between most industrialized countries for those in the first standard deviation (aka. most people). It's kinda like the Olympics, if you're in the top 10 you're doing fine. If one is selecting a country to live in, it's likely better to optimize for your own situation rather than optimizing from a bunch of HDI/GDP/Freedom type reports. It's like a friend said of China, probably one of the most free places on earth because he could stay out drinking all night. For him it was more important that bars were open because he likes to drink than it was to be able to protest the government. For instance there is pretty much no way I'd ever live in Singapore; Singapore makes US drug policy look downright progressive.
- _delirium 13y agoI dunno, I'm from the U.S., and now live in Denmark, and it feels much nicer socioeconomically. They are both in the top 10, and the U.S. actually has a higher median income, but the subjective difference to me is huge. Not in the mean or median, but in the general feeling that there is far less poverty. Even bad parts of Copenhagen are nothing like the bad parts of Atlanta (same goes for other cities I've lived in, like Chicago and Los Angeles). You don't really have to watch yourself nearly as much. When I lived in Atlanta, you needed a lot of fairly specific knowledge about which areas of the city were safe, sometimes even which specific streets were okay to walk on at night. And the unsafe ones were unsafe in the "people get mugged here daily" sort of way, whereas the Copenhagen unsafe neighborhoods are more like "someone was mugged here 6 weeks ago and it's still in the news". Homeless people are much more rare; things like people living in trailer parks are also very rare. There is no safety problem biking 10km alone at 4am half-drunk; in fact it is not too uncommon to do so. And even poor people seem to have fairly normal lives, not that different from mine. They rent non-squalid apartments, send their kids to ok schools, have good medical care, etc. I'm not sure how to quantify that subjective feeling of the general level feeling wealthier, but one guess might be to look at Nth-percentile incomes for your choice of lower bound N. The U.S. has a higher median income than Denmark. But a bound that half the people fall below (N=50) doesn't give you strong guarantees. How do their 10th-percentile incomes compare? I.e. what is the lower bound that >90% of Americans meet, vs. the lower bound that >90% of Danes meet? IIRC, it's considerably higher in Denmark, which might explain why it subjectively feels wealthier to me—the income $x where you can assume "probably almost everyone makes at least $x" for some reasonable choice of "almost everyone" (80%, 90%, 95%, somewhere in that range) is higher.