2 ms·
Machines are mindlessly obedient. The technology is not an actor here. What matters is who controls the data. That person is the one effectively performing t
by logfromblammo 13y ago
Machines are mindlessly obedient. The technology is not an actor here.
What matters is who controls the data. That person is the one effectively performing the surveillance. If you eliminate the force multiplier as a separate entity, what you see is that one or more Alexandria cops are ruthlessly hounding everyone that enters their city.
I presume that the collected data are not being published freely, probably using "ongoing investigation" and "officer safety" as a cover. I further presume that the data are being correlated and mined for the purpose of identifying criminals and assembling evidence against them, and the algorithms in use do not likewise search the records for exculpatory evidence for those who already stand accused.
The failing is not that cops are using powerful technologies to aid their work. The failing is that the police departments themselves have no technology remedy for their long-standing human failings. Rather than tracing a verifiable harm from victim to perpetrator, focusing on the facts of the case, and leaving matters of justice to the mechanisms of the courts, cops are increasingly filling quotas for their citations and encounters, punishing people on their own prerogative, and enjoying an asymmetric relationship with the public.
You want to watch us? We must ask qui custodiet custodes? Before training your cameras on the public, first point them at yourselves, and show us that you are trustworthy. Are cops prepared to confront the video evidence that they engaged a prostitute while on duty and then took a nap in their patrol car? Stop pretending that a smartphone camera is in any way equivalent to a gun. Before I am willing to tolerate in any way the trappings of the panopticon, every last cop out there, from bicycle patrol rookie to the city commander, should be willing to have a camera on his badge and uniform from the moment it is donned to the instant it is doffed, with an uncut record freely available at some point to the public.
Now, I wouldn't like having someone hanging over my shoulder all the time making sure I'm not reading HN at work, either. But sometimes you have to experience it personally before you can empathize with the person you intend to inflict that upon.