3 ms·
>I don't like the idea of forbidding someone to remember things they've seen (heard, received, observed - whatever verb's appropriate). The state is not people
by pessimizer 13y ago
>I don't like the idea of forbidding someone to remember things they've seen (heard, received, observed - whatever verb's appropriate).
The state is not people. The state is a fiction that we use to do things in the way that we've collectively decided is appropriate. We order it to forget things all the time e.g. illegally discovered evidence, juvenile criminal histories, things ordered struck from the record in court, etc.
Anthropomorphizing the state is dangerous.
- mpyne 13y agoAnd yet the courts have already affirmatively confirmed that the police are not required to "pretend not to see" something in public view, or that they saw in plain sight in the course of a legal search. By the way, knowing what is normal for a neighborhood is very much in the definition of "good old fashioned police work" that I've seen trotted out around here before.
- pessimizer 13y ago>courts have already affirmatively confirmed that the police are not required to "pretend not to see" something in public view, or that they saw in plain sight in the course of a legal search. This is the process, yes. They don't gain these abilities as some sort of natural right. Neither of these are a dragnet over the general populace, or the creation of a record of every observation during that dragnet for computer-aided analysis, so they should expect to be in court for this too. The current court would probably be very friendly to their arguments, no matter what they are.
- angersock 13y agoYou've hit the nail on the head--infringing on an individual's right to remember something is nuts, but requiring that group entities (governments, corporations, etc.) have certain forms of acute amnesia is quite reasonable. One of the reasons for this is that most of those entities are not able to be reasoned with or to show empathy in any meaningful capacity--they'll bear stances which appear to be petty grudges for years, sometimes decades, because that's the sort of timescale they can operate on. Intuitions for individuals do not and can not apply to organizations.