5 ms·
Harvard scholars may have been duped by a forged ‘Gospel of Jesus’s Wife’
- nateabele 13y agoHeh, forget the technical considerations. A manuscript fragment of massive historical implications being passed to them by an 'anonymous source'? That's improbable enough by itself.
- abuari 13y agoWith how archaeology evolved as a field and the current black market, it is not surprising to have an anonymous source for an historical artifact.
- KevinEldon 13y agoWith how Jesus scholarship as a field has evolved and how achademia as an industry operates, it is not surprising that a "scholar" was duped.
- dang 13y agoI believe this is right. The trade in ancient manuscripts is surprisingly cloak-and-dagger. (Edit: I base this on such vast experience as having read a couple New Yorker articles about it.)
- awhitty 13y agoJust curious, but how do you get in the loop on the ancient manuscript trade? It's not even an area of work I have ever thought about before.
- existencebox 13y agoPotentially unrelated, but I had some very brief conversations with a paleontologist I worked for a while back (working for a very respectable public institution) about black market fossil trade; it's VERY common (and often fronted through "legitimate" fossil/mineral traders) and if you're at all in the academic side of obtaining these sorts of items, you very readily run into people obtaining them for many sources, and get a better view of the "flow" of these items. I would imagine similar fields (in terms of dealing with "historical" items of value) have similar black market systems.
- WalterBright 13y agoEh, with such a small fragment, couldn't the article have given a translation of what it says?
- pfortuny 13y agoI gather it must just be a collection of parts of senteces, not what you would call a "fragment" but just several of them (the papyrus does not seem to contain whole lines, as I see it). But I may be wrong. Or not.
- jessaustin 13y agoI think one of the lines is: Then Jesus said, "Take my wife... please!"
- pan69 13y agoDoes anyone know how common the name "Jesus" was in those days? For all we know it could the equivalent of John or Mark today..
- ijk 13y agoSuper common in the 1st century, since it's a form of Joshua. Not that it would have any bearing on this document, with its vastly later date. http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/2008/12/happy_birthday_dear_yeshua_happy_birthday_to_you.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/20...
- ijk 13y agoIn general, I'd prefer it if more popular media included technical details (like full translations) in their articles. The places I've been finding translations are mostly the blogs of interested academics. The second fragment is a Coptic translation of (parts of) John 6:11-14. [1] Wikipedia has a translation of the text from Dr. King's original article. [2] [1] http://alinsuciu.com/2014/04/24/christian-askeland-finds-the-smoking-gun/ http://alinsuciu.com/2014/04/24/christian-askeland-finds-the... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gospel_of_Jesus'_Wife http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gospel_of_Jesus'_Wife
- patrickg_zill 13y agoGiven these stories, I sometimes wonder if 750 years from now, a copy of the National Enquirer will be found in pristine condition, and, it will be taken as representative of today's society... people will start using "Kardashian" as an archaic honorific, for example...
- kefka 13y agoYep. Those Kardashians are a real pain. Especially Gul Kim.
- dkuntz2 13y agoI thought she was still only a glinn.
- trhway 13y agowhat would be the difference between people 750 year in the future looking at Kardashian images (or various adult Internet content of today) and us looking at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venus_figurines http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venus_figurines ? Would they come to the same conclusions about Matriarchy and Goddesses of Fertility?
- jessaustin 13y agoIf the forger had used italics in addition, one might be in danger of losing one’s composure. Those theologians. So droll.
- coldtea 13y agoThere several "gnostic gospels" from all around Roman times, that mention whatever the authors intended. It's not like those are unknown, it's that they don't reflect the canonical body chosen by the Christian faith. It's like discovering a fan-fiction of Star Wars were Obi Wan is a cross-dresser. Might be amusing, but it's not the canonical version of the story. It's not like yet another gospel can change that.