4 ms·
I like that this actually covers why each piece is needed. My only beef with this system is the proof of work, which leads to an arms race in electricity consu
by EGreg 13y ago
I like that this actually covers why each piece is needed.
My only beef with this system is the proof of work, which leads to an arms race in electricity consumption. Proof of stake is better, and frankly, distributed timestamps don't need a race to solve a problem every time something has to be timestamped.
For currency, it would actually be nicer to have a system that treats trust/credit/reputation as the scarce resource. It would help people who aren't rich in the traditional sense nevertheless organize and help each other, and would allow people to "create their own currency" in communities, or the equivalent of that, that they aren't able to do now.
- bjitty 13y agoI'm familiar with proof of work and how it works within a blockchain to secure blocks. I keep hearing about prof of stake. I'm very interested in it, however I haven't found an explanation that clearly explains to me how it works. I've looked at the Wiki article and read a little about Peercoin. Do you know of any article, video or source that may help explain exactly how proof of stake works?
- flatline 13y agoIf you haven't read the peercoin whitepaper[1], it may get you a bit closer to an understanding. That being said, I still don't have a solid grasp of exactly how coins destroyed results in solving blocks... [1] http://www.peercoin.net/whitepaper http://www.peercoin.net/whitepaper
- bjitty 13y agoThank you! I can't believe I missed it and didn't think to check for a white paper for this. Especially since that's what really cleared up bitcoin's proof of work blockchain to me.
- bachback 13y agoproof of stake was first proposed in 2011 on bitcointalk, the go-to reference for everything bitcoin/altcoin. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Proof_of_Stake https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Proof_of_Stake http://wiki.nxtcrypto.org/ http://wiki.nxtcrypto.org/ http://bitshares.org/security/delegated-proof-of-stake.php http://bitshares.org/security/delegated-proof-of-stake.php If any coins make it you can see at watching the marketcap of the coins at http://coinmarketcap.com http://coinmarketcap.com
- bjitty 13y agoAwesome, thanks for the links.
- nomailing 13y agoI would recommend reading http://blog.ethereum.org/2014/01/15/slasher-a-punitive-proof-of-stake-algorithm/ http://blog.ethereum.org/2014/01/15/slasher-a-punitive-proof...
- bjitty 13y agoThanks I appreciate it. Off to read it now.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gnaritas 13y ago> Proof of stake is better, It sounds like it should be, but it isn't, lacking PoW, there's no reason not to create many possible blocks and without central check-pointing the whole thing falls apart. The problem with proof of stake is that nothing is at stake.
- bachback 13y agothat part of the problem is partially solved. not every node has to "mine" all blocks. in fact in PoS there's no mining at all. the big problem is that you create all coins at genesis. there are a bunch of proposals and work in this direction.
- nomailing 13y agoNo. That is not a problem. Please read about the Slasher proof of stake algorithm. It is very easy to punish the creator of many possible blocks. People always use this nonesense phrase that "with proof of stake nothing is at stake". That is no problem. If the protocol allows that your mining profit is taken away and given to the next honest stakeholder then why do you say that it is a problem that nothing is at stake.
- gnaritas 13y agoYes it is a problem and last I checked, there's still no working PoS implementation that doesn't rely on central check-pointing. "Slasher" is an idea (likely full of unforeseen issues), not an implementation and until there's a working implementation that doesn't rely on central check-pointing, PoS is vapor-ware.
- maaku 13y agoNo, it's very easy to convince yourself that these problems are solved when they in fact are not. I have not seen any proof-of-stake mechanism which does not either require centralization (despite claims to the contrary), or devolve into proof-of-work as miners grind blocks until they find one that names themselves or one of their sock puppets as the next signer.
- toasted 13y agoi agree about the arms race, however block reward halving will diminish electricity requirements in a stepwise fashion and lessen the impact of this problem over time