4 ms·
Ah, those heady days of the 80s and 90s, where CASE tools and object-oriented programming were going to save the world. Hell, with CASE tools we wouldn't even n
by mikestew 13y ago
Ah, those heady days of the 80s and 90s, where CASE tools and object-oriented programming were going to save the world. Hell, with CASE tools we wouldn't even need programmers anymore, folks will just enter the requirements and compilable code will come out the other end!
The world of computing machinery was rife with that bullshit around that time, more so than before because most folks had never used a computer to do something useful and up to that time computers were mostly ginormous calculators or data sorters. I think the industry today has finally found a bit of skepticism (and cynicism) thanks to such fiascos as the FAA's project and because $100,000 CASE tools proved to be largely a waste of money. Object-oriented programming eventually found its place in the world, but I think it, too, was largely oversold in the late 80s and early 90s.
So then we were left in an in-between time where we were beginning to discover the magic that computers can work, but had not yet developed the necessary level of skepticism needed to sniff out the snake oil.
The article in one sense lays the blame at the feet of old-school Big Bang development. We, the readers, of course are wondering "did you not read The Mythical Man Month?" But it's my recollection that the snake oil, umm, I mean "tools" of the time were said to save us from such pitfalls. But many forgot to read the chapter on "There is No Silver Bullet" (or maybe that was a later paper, not in the book).
Though the dollar amount is huge, it's still the same old story that plays out to this day: magical tools (replace CASE with MongoDB, node, or whatever) that may have a use but don't pack the punch the vendor says it does, vendors that don't want to say "no, that's not practical" and ever-changing requirements from customers. Some 20, 30 years later we don't seem to have collectively learned a whole lot.
- cheepin 13y agoOO is still oversold in my opinion. Functional programming may be an up and coming star, but OO dominates industry still.
- phaedrus 13y agoThe problem with CASE tools is that any system composed of "(CONFIGURATION+CASE_TOOL) => (GENERATED_CODE+COMPILER) => STATIC_PROGRAM" could be replaced with just "DYNAMIC_PROGRAM + CONFIGURATION". The generation of the source code and then compiling it is an unnecessary middle step.