3 ms·

As a python data novice, question about ipython notebooks: Do people tend to edit and view them in the included web service, or is there a way to set it up to u

As a python data novice, question about ipython notebooks: Do people tend to edit and view them in the included web service, or is there a way to set it up to use your preferred editor while still having the notebook visualization experience?

TimSAstro 12y ago
The raw representation is a somewhat cluttered (to the untrained eye, anyway) json file - especially if you have checkpointed images which are bascially base64 encoded blobs! So as far as I know it's pretty much the web-editor or nothing at the moment. Obviously a JSON-aware plug-in for something like PyDev or Pycharm would be pretty neat, but I think we're a ways off that. See also http://nbdiff.org/ http://nbdiff.org/ which solves the issue of comparing version-tracked notebooks.
squishyphysics 12y ago
There are IPython Notebook implementations for VI and Emacs which mirror much of the rich interface of the notebook. However, they do NOT include the Javascript support needed for these rich interfaces. There's also a QT frontend that can display graphics. IPython is two separate pieces - a core kernel, and a frontend that communicates with it via a published protocol. Anybody can design any client they want to interact with the kernel. The notebook interface in the browser is definitely the richest, in terms of features.
- bencpeters 12y ago
  Tangentially related - but if you're a vim fan and want to be able to use the full, in-browser notebook, you can easily set up vim bindings by following these instructions: http://spaceli.wordpress.com/2013/10/04/add-vim-key-bindings-for-ipython-1-0-0/ http://spaceli.wordpress.com/2013/10/04/add-vim-key-bindings... (the post was for iPython 1.0, but it seems to still work with 2.0) This feature alone made me 10x more excited to use iPython notebook as a development environment.
bpowah 12y ago
For more involved explorations, I use the editor of my choice and import/reload the script as a module in the notebook.
zokier 12y ago
IPython has %edit and %run "magics" (and probably some others that I don't know about) that be used for editor-based workflow. There are also some plugins for Vim and Emacs, but I don't have experience with those.

TimSAstro 12y ago

The raw representation is a somewhat cluttered (to the untrained eye, anyway) json file - especially if you have checkpointed images which are bascially base64 encoded blobs! So as far as I know it's pretty much the web-editor or nothing at the moment. Obviously a JSON-aware plug-in for something like PyDev or Pycharm would be pretty neat, but I think we're a ways off that. See also http://nbdiff.org/ http://nbdiff.org/ which solves the issue of comparing version-tracked notebooks.

squishyphysics 12y ago

There are IPython Notebook implementations for VI and Emacs which mirror much of the rich interface of the notebook. However, they do NOT include the Javascript support needed for these rich interfaces. There's also a QT frontend that can display graphics. IPython is two separate pieces - a core kernel, and a frontend that communicates with it via a published protocol. Anybody can design any client they want to interact with the kernel. The notebook interface in the browser is definitely the richest, in terms of features.

bencpeters 12y ago
Tangentially related - but if you're a vim fan and want to be able to use the full, in-browser notebook, you can easily set up vim bindings by following these instructions: http://spaceli.wordpress.com/2013/10/04/add-vim-key-bindings-for-ipython-1-0-0/ http://spaceli.wordpress.com/2013/10/04/add-vim-key-bindings... (the post was for iPython 1.0, but it seems to still work with 2.0) This feature alone made me 10x more excited to use iPython notebook as a development environment.

bpowah 12y ago

For more involved explorations, I use the editor of my choice and import/reload the script as a module in the notebook.

zokier 12y ago

IPython has %edit and %run "magics" (and probably some others that I don't know about) that be used for editor-based workflow. There are also some plugins for Vim and Emacs, but I don't have experience with those.