5 ms·
America the Shrunken
- mark_l_watson 13y agoI submitted the his article because it reflects the change in psychological outlook that I see: an undercurrent of pessimism with a layer of denial. Strange combination. For the last decade or two, I have felt optimistic about my own future while really concerned about that of the USA in general.
- FD3SA 13y agoThe topic is relevant, but the article is extremely vacuous. There is literally no content other than random opinion polls. For those interested in some of the facts underlying this assertion, please read Capital by Thomas Piketty, or watch Paul Krugman give an excellent summary of it [1]. 1. http://billmoyers.com/episode/what-the-1-dont-want-you-to-know-2/ http://billmoyers.com/episode/what-the-1-dont-want-you-to-kn...
- mark_l_watson 13y agoThanks, I am adding Piketty's book to my reading list.
- hga 13y agoSomething is going on. After 9/11, Americans started buying non-hunting type guns in unprecedented quantities (and that got really wild after Obama's election, with an ammunition shortage that's not ended (confounding factor for the latter, it's after the time the Cold War stocks of surplus military ammo got exhausted)). There are confounding factors, e.g. America is aging as the huge demographic bulge of the Baby Boomers age, and that especially combined with a nationwide sweep of shall issue concealed carry regimes has resulted in a lot of these older folk, perhaps realizing they're less able to physically protect themselves, buying guns and getting concealed carry permits (my class for that in SW Missouri was overwhelmingly middle aged or older). (If Puerta v. County of San Diego is upheld, which is the way to bet, 90% of the nation's population will be covered, already it's much easier to list the few states that don't do shall issue.) ADDED: but that doesn't explain the run on rifles of military utility.... I think a factor was the government's response which essentially told us we were on our own (more details if desired). But this is fine grained hard data, due to the taxation regime for guns and ammo (used to fund hunting favorable conservation stuff, ranges to a certain extent and perhaps more of than going forward, etc.), here we don't have to depend on anecdotes, surveys, etc.
- gammagoblin 13y agoPersonally I hope the USA quiets down and accepts that one nation cannot lead the entire world without a fully globalised society (and even then I doubt the idea is very good, but that's another discussion entirely). The problem I, as a European, have with the USA is that the government sees itself to have the moral authority to intervene in other countries' internal affairs to change our politics to their interests or pull us with them into their own wars. I've not spoken to a single person here in Europe who supports military intervention in the middle east, and to be honest I think the intervention of both the previous Soviet government and the current U.S. government is what breeds terrorism and threats from extremists. The USA has - as a result of the cold war's and the current interventions in other countries - expanded the role of the NSA, set up extensive airport security programs such as the TSA, and through Homeland Security they scrutinise every tourist's history to the greatest of detail before actually letting them in. The ESTA application is only the surface of such. I consider the US government to be a very dangerous institution to safety and security for all human beings around the world. I sincerely hope that the American public puts the US back on the right track. The current foreign policy is economically and socially unsustainable, the welfare state in the USA is crumbling and the middle class is shrinking at an alarming rate. The government seriously needs a big change. I am not encouraging revolutionary action, as I believe any government that needs violence to be instated is inherently flawed, but there needs to be a change. There's a lot of focus on the wrong issues in the USA, especially amongst the youth, while the entire nation is heading towards economical and social regression.
- waps 13y agoAs a fellow European, I find this attitude baffling. Your complaints about the US: airport security interference, of the soft political kind, in other countries military intervention in the middle east (and Russia/Eastern Europe, which you left out, yet it was far more important than the middle east will ever be. And hell, if Putin doesn't back off, it may happen yet again) Okay ... Now let's open the history books, go back to before American hegemony, the 1918-1945 period. Britain and France in charge, with some lesser powers having a bit of clout in a few remote places. Do I really need to remind you what happened ? I don't just mean WWII, rather all the events leading up to it more than the actual event. The economic crises, not getting a few people fired, but throwing large populations into famine. Do you think, had you lived in that period, your complaints would have been about travelling security, political power of foreign countries ? Go ahead, ask your grandfather how society worked, what they were afraid of ... and the things that happened to them. Ask a Jew, and I'm not just talking about WWII. Go ahead, enquire about the period preceding the war. Then go back a bit further. How was life, in Europe, during the revolutionary era, culminating in the creation of Soviet Russia ? Do you really want that, because that's what the society of Europe created ? It was one period of history where there is no denying : the people were in charge (or at least, they were the driving force behind the big changes). Robespierre. Napoleon. Constant wars, for moronic reasons. The eternal holy war of the muslims against Europe was still going, even if no longer at full blast, it may be downplayed now, but was a VERY real thing influencing the lives of a great many people very, very badly. I mean, I'm not saying America really is the "shining city on the hill", BUT let's call a spade a spade here : American hegemony has been pretty fucking great for America, for Europe, for the whole world. Denying that makes you a moron, nothing more. Let me state the blatantly obvious here : without American power being unassailable, maybe not globally, but at least on every ocean, our world will get a whole lot worse, very fast. Very fast. Once it happens it will take half a millennium to get liveable again. Can you at least consider for 5 seconds that knowing nothing about history and just having lived the last 30 years might not provide an entirely realistic view of how the world works ? And if by globalized society you mean the UN, I suggest you check out the UN's successes. Oh wait. I'm looking over the list here. First there was the "League of nations", the UN. List of successes ... it's getting blamed for WWII, that's certainly a big thing I hear. But no worries ... the UN is so much better. They started out with the Katanga mission ... no sane person can call that a success. But surely things improved after that ? So then we have their attempts at negotiating truces between Russia and Eastern Europe. Great success for Russia, those ... Then the creation and various division(s) of Israel, and the UN's constant assurances of peace and peace treaties ... followed by massive attacks. That went so very nicely. Other highlights : Rwanda, Yugoslavia, Kuwait, Western Sahara, ... No offence but the "globalized society" is not just a disaster, many people would have been better off living under a dictator ordering a genocide against them than with the result of having the "globalized society" that is the UN interfere with their affairs.
- tptacek 13y agoI flagged this article because I can't imagine a civil, productive, germane thread that could emanate from it. Flag it with me, or prove me wrong, I guess.
- Ensorceled 13y agoWhy does it need to promote discussion at all? Is it not a useful read standalone?
- dasil003 13y agoTo be fair, civil, productive and germane is a pretty tall order for any thread on the internet.
- itbeho 13y agoI think the content of the article is insightful and aligns with what I and some friends were recently discussing. There seems to be a growing sense of pessimism (outside the tech scene anyway) in middle class America. I don't really know the cause but I think it's worth discussing further.
- mark_l_watson 13y agoI posted this article. At least in my family and circle of friends, this is a much discussed topic. That said, I agree that HN should be mostly for technology.
- BugBrother 13y agoIsn't there too much theorizing and teeth gnashing? With Asia's fast rise and outsourcing, the increase in global work force has been much faster than the increase in capital investments. It seems natural that while that happens, the average salaries will go down [or at a minimum stagnate] for the middle class in the old rich countries (supply/demand), since there are lots of well educated people coming from a poor environment. USA already had larger GINI coefficients than the rest of the western world, which is natural with the size (more heterogenous). So the median values etc for living standards will reflect that.
- dctoedt 13y agoAll motion is relative: It's been said that what we're seeing is not so much the decline of the West, as it is the rise of the rest. That might make some of us feel bad here in the U.S. --- we're no longer the undisputed top dogs in the world, as we were post-WWII --- but (to put it mildly) it's not entirely a bad thing for our fellow human beings in non-U.S. countries to be enjoying a higher standard of living than they had before. The essence of "Americanism," it seems to me, is a desire to do better, for ourselves and our posterity (to paraphrase the preamble of the U.S. Constitution). That's not a quality unique to the U.S., of course, but we put a lot of emphasis on it. The mere existence of the linked article, and those like it, suggests we haven't entirely lost that quality; we shouldn't begrudge it when other countries and cultures "win" as well. EDIT, responding to @waps: This issue is orthogonal to the question of how order can be maintained while still preserving peace, prosperity, and liberty. If there's an alternative to a light-touch military dominance by the U.S. and its allies, I'm not aware of it.
- waps 13y agoThere is just the tiny problem of what the military world order China will support (although I'm thankful it's not the middle east). This seems to me a pretty serious problem, and frankly the reason they will not stay the biggest for long. But it's going to hurt everyone, just like it did before. People forget what history looked like before the "pax Americana", because it's lasted more than a generation now. Even before that there was the colonial "peace" (compared to what came before it, it certainly was peaceful, compared to after, maybe not so peaceful), so even the pre-baby-boomer generation does not really remember what was the norm of history before WWI. Let's just hope it'll all be different this time. That China will not do what it did in the early medieval times. That either the middle east will not reunite, or that it somehow will act differently this time. That the Russian situation does not resume the cold war (which wasn't all that cold in Eastern Europe as plenty of Americans know first-hand). There is the strategic theory that there has been peace because of the superpowers. Let's just hope that that is very wrong, and that it can survive 3 or 4 superpowers.
- hga 13y agoLook up the volume of world trade before WWI, and just how long it took to get back up to that level. Much, much later than you'd think. Looking the results of the of the infinitely more brutal Pax Romana should give anyone pause at the prospect of the end of the Pax Americana.
- carsongross 13y agoThis is the liberal view. Take a few moments, if you can, and put yourselves in the mind of a conservative american. Consider what things look like to a conservative christian in favor of small government, living in a town whose industrial base has been nuked and who is now living through a construction bust, with no obvious "next thing" in sight, except perhaps uprooting their families to the Dakotas for oil jobs. If we don't make room for them, there will, eventually, be war.
- hga 13y agoI have to run soon, so ask for details and I'll reply in a few hours, but from our viewpoint it's much worse, we're already on the currently losing side of an active cold civil war, legal (e.g. gun control, except we're current massively winning there), cultural, social and economic at minimum, and are very concerned it will get hot in the foreseeable future. That's very possibly another reason for https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7694454 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7694454
- waps 13y agoThis is the great problem of liberals in the US. World-wide of course it's a far greater problem. Liberals espouse democracy, but the majority of the US wants religion, conservativeness and the like. World-wide the situation is far, far worse. In case you haven't yet noticed, most of the world still isn't Christian, and every other faith wants some variation of killing gays ... some faiths want them killed on sight even. The number of people wanting that is not really known, but reasonably, it's somewhere between 4 and 5 billion. Liberalism is self-interest of middle class and upper-middle class people. But as you say, those social classes are disappearing, and not just because they don't seem to be having any kids. The sad truth is, unless something fundamentally changes, the end of liberalism won't need to wait until the next generation, because those classes are being eliminated. You could say that it's economic policy, but that's not really true. I'd say technology and improved large-scale efficiency is mostly responsible. And that's inside America and Europe, in the rest of the world nothing remotely resembling liberalism stands a snowball's chance in hell of getting 10% of the votes.
- lhgaghl 13y agoI'm having trouble reading this article. It seems to make a giant bar that takes up a large percentage of my screen as I scroll through it: http://image.bayimg.com/6f1dce58aa37b2825e74cec05895180a147350db.jpg http://image.bayimg.com/6f1dce58aa37b2825e74cec05895180a1473... Anyone know how to turn it off?