4 ms·
It's getting more and more common these days that whenever I talk to people about travel, the US is completely off their list. As people in the United States w
by tokenadult 13y ago
It's getting more and more common these days that whenever I talk to people about travel, the US is completely off their list.
As people in the United States wake up on a Sunday morning in their time zones, I guess it falls on me to say that this all depends on whom you talk to. I know lots of people who desire to visit the United States. The United States is still second only to France as the country most visited by tourists from other countries.[1] That's remarkable to me because France has land borders with several other countries, all countries with large populations, while the United States mostly has to be reached by transoceanic air travel.
The original post says, "I have heard that if I have been to some countries I might be refused to enter the US." What it does not say is, "I have checked the United States laws and have checked actual practice of what happens at the United States border, to see how that compares with border control in other countries." And then there are a couple of anecdotes in the few responses. This is basically not a high-quality submission for Hacker News, as it doesn't promote the thoughtful, informed discussion that should characterize our community here.
The typical set of Hacker News comments about the United States from people who have never been to the United States seems to mingle two points of view. On the one hand, the United States is criticized as an undesirable place that no one would want to live in or even visit, given a choice. On the other hand, the United States is criticized as an inhospitable place that doesn't give free, unrestricted entry to anyone who wants to work or visit or settle in the United States. (Criticisms of United States immigration policy on Hacker News mostly take the form of saying that the United States should let in more immigrants like, um, the people who participate on Hacker News.) A fable attributed to the Greek author Aesop[2] may explain how these seemingly contrary opinions of the United States can exist in the mind of the same person.
[1] http://www.smh.com.au/travel/travel-news/the-worlds-most-popular-country-for-tourists-in-2013-20140124-31cx0.html http://www.smh.com.au/travel/travel-news/the-worlds-most-pop...
http://time.com/10296/most-popular-countries-to-visit-map/ http://time.com/10296/most-popular-countries-to-visit-map/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Tourism_rankings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Tourism_rankings
(Some sources disagree on the exact ranking, but every source I checked puts France first and puts the United States in the top five.)
[2] http://www.bartleby.com/17/1/31.html http://www.bartleby.com/17/1/31.html
- VexXtreme 13y agoNo offense but the tone of your post screams 'butthurt'. Leave your national pride and various statistics-based pissing contests out of this (and the sour grapes argument is completely emotion-based and irrelevant). There are many legitimate reasons for non-Americans to avoid the US these days and unpleasant immigration procedures are just one of them. I am for one simply afraid of going there, not knowing what kind of horrible treatment I can expect at the border if I rub some immigration officer the wrong way, and this is coming from a white European. Many of my friends feel the same way. I can only imagine what a Middle Eastern-looking person with a few stamps from 'undesirable' countries in their passport must feel like.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoYeah politics suck. I remember when my older brother travelled to India to visit the in-laws. Unfortunately for him some American customs folk had turned away an Indian diplomat the previous day. So it was 'turn Americans away day' and he was the unfortunate pawn. Too a couple of days before it blew over.
- tokenadult 13y agoI have lived outside the United States (in a non-Western, non-English-speaking country) for a large percentage of my adult life, so I am very open to the perspective of people from other countries. And as I have done my own crossing of international borders, I see that each country sets its own rules about who crosses with what kind of paperwork. Unrestricted discretion of border control officers is the general rule of international law, alas, despite a period of history (before when any of us were born) when it was routine for most people to be allowed to travel freely to most civilized countries. I don't imagine what people feel like when I can observe what people feel like. What I observe is that a lot more people on Hacker News and elsewhere desire to visit the United States and to settle in the United States[1] than decide never to go to the United States at all. That's a fact of the world that I have to deal with without emotion or name-calling but just by thinking about what policy implications that fact has. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/dec/14/united-states-immigration-numbers-perucca http://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/dec/14/united-states-i... http://www.pewresearch.org/daily-number/u-s-is-top-destination-for-worlds-migrants/ http://www.pewresearch.org/daily-number/u-s-is-top-destinati...