3 ms·
It is disingenuous to position a "kill switch" as the best alternative. Kill switches can be circumvented. Phones can be sold for parts. And it's an excuse for
by Zigurd 13y ago
It is disingenuous to position a "kill switch" as the best alternative. Kill switches can be circumvented. Phones can be sold for parts. And it's an excuse for police to be unresponsive.
Whereas if phones can be located, it seems like a great opportunity for repossession companies to offer a phone retrieval service, and for police to aggregate data on recovered phone to identify theft rings.
- probably_wrong 13y agoI'm not sure I agree with that point of view. Phones currently can be located, and yet there are no repossession services around already. And police is already unresponsive when it comes to this* (I don't know if they uncover theft rings, though). I think phones fall under the same category as bikes - good resale price, low risk[1]. A kill switch doesn't have to be perfect, I think. It only needs to be hard enough to circumvent to make the effort worthless, the same way that the woman in the article found her phone despite it being relatively easy to circumvent the "find my phone" feature. * Results may vary according to your city and country. [1] http://blog.priceonomics.com/post/30393216796/what-happens-to-stolen-bicycles http://blog.priceonomics.com/post/30393216796/what-happens-t...
- PeterisP 13y agoI believe that kill switches. In my area at around year 2000, when 'dumbphones' were common but still rather pricey, theft or mugging of phones was a common crime. It dropped significantly overnight when IMEI blacklists were implemented and reported stolen phones wouldn't work on local networks. There were still some thefts of luxury phones, where it made sense to export them abroad, but it was a huge reduction. Even if kill switches can be circumvented and phones can be sold for parts - it significantly reduces the incentive for someone to steal phones, as selling them is more effort and less money; such changes do affect behavior of criminals.
- JTxt 13y agoThe idea of a kill switch is great if it can only be controlled by the owner of the device. (The person that purchased it to use.) But we have not solved that problem yet. We are still using short passwords instead of strong private keys; we give unencrypted access of our data to cloud providers to make things easier for us. How can ultimate authority/access of our property be made user friendly enough for joe user/sixpack?
- im3w1l 13y agoOne solution could be to prompt "do you want this computer to be able to killswitch the phone" first time you connect the phone to a computer. Under the hood it creates a shared secret that when sent to the phone bricks it.
- Zigurd 13y agoIMEI blacklists are unimplemented in many places. On many phones, the IMEI can be changed. Even though there are laws against reprogramming IMEIs, there are plenty of how-tos on the Internet. Stolen phones ended up in Russia and India, after having their IMEIs reprogrammed by professional fences. Many carriers opposed mandatory IMEI blacklisting laws/regulations on the grounds it is ineffective.
- PeterisP 13y agoThat's the whole point - IMEI blacklists successfully reduced street crime despite that there were available workarounds such as reprogramming and/or export to Russia. This gives an expectation that killswitches also can achieve their crime reduction goals even if professional fences are able to circumvent the killswitches.