3 ms·
> In fact, the idea of "approaches" cannot happen with just rational numbers. Yes, it can. The sequence 0.9, 0.99, 0.999, ... is entirely composed of rational
by pdonis 13y ago
> In fact, the idea of "approaches" cannot happen with just rational numbers.
Yes, it can. The sequence 0.9, 0.99, 0.999, ... is entirely composed of rational numbers, and its limit is also a rational number.
The issue with rational numbers is that there are sequences which are composed entirely of rational numbers but do not have limits that are rational numbers. An example is 1.4, 1.41, 1.414, ..., i.e., successive truncations of the decimal expansion of sqrt(2). The limit of the sequence is sqrt(2) itself, which is irrational. So in that particular case, the concept of "taking the limit of a sequence" can't be applied within the rational numbers. But that doesn't mean it can't be applied at all; you just need to restrict to sequences that have rational limits.
- ColinWright 13y agoJust a thought ... euank> In fact, the idea of "approaches" cannot euank> happen with just rational numbers. pdonis> Yes, it can. The sequence 0.9, 0.99, 0.999, ... pdonis> is entirely composed of rational numbers, and its pdonis> limit is also a rational number. Everything you write is correct, but I think you're refuting something that wasn't intended. I think euank's comment meant that you can't have a concept of "approaches" when you're just dealing with single values. That's what the "just" is intended to mean, you're "just" dealing with numbers, not with sequences. With that reading your comment is misplaced, although I can completely understand the interpretation you put on it, and were that what had been intended, your comment would have been well stated.