3 ms·
The comment to which this is a reply has been deleted. To give this comment (its siblings) context, there is the text: Yes I meant that. It makes no sense
by ColinWright 13y ago
The comment to which this is a reply has been deleted. To give this comment (its siblings) context, there is the text:
Yes I meant that. It makes no sense, because with
that flawed logic you can formulate the following:
1/3 = 0.3... -> 0.3... * 3 = 0.9... -> 0.9.. = 3/3 = 1
If anything, 0.9... APPROACHES 1. Something like
0.9... ~ 1 is a better notation.
Consider the expression 0.9999...
It's easy to write syntactic nonsense, so it's not obvious that this has any meaning at all. However, if you are going to give that a meaning, then the most reasonable meaning to assign is that it's the limit of the sequence:
0.9, 0.99, 0.999, 0.9999, 0.99999, ...
The limit is 1. The terms of the sequence approach 1, yes, but the limit does not approach anything because it doesn't move and it doesn't change. The limit is a value, and that value is 1.
Your comment about 0.999... approaching 1 is genuinely wrong, and very, very misleading.
It's even more wrong (whatever that means) to say that 0.9999... ~ 1. That's genuinely not a better notation. The interpretation of the meaning of the expression 0.9999... as given above does not allow that the expression 0.9999... should have any value other than 1.[0]
[0] Assuming you're working in the standard reals, which form the Archimedean totally ordered complete infinite field. If you're in non-standard analysis then that's something completely different.