6 ms·
Two Equals Four (2011)
- jds375 13y agoThis does not work because it does not converge for the number 4. The equation x^x^x^x^...=y is only valid for y in the range e^-1 < y < e, although proving this is a bit complicated. More info on hyperpowers can be found here: (http://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/jmac/ther/tower.htm http://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/jmac/ther/tower.htm). The proof can be found here: (http://www.maa.org/sites/default/files/pdf/upload_library/22/Chauvenet/Knoebelchv.pdf http://www.maa.org/sites/default/files/pdf/upload_library/22...)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- throwaway13qf85 13y agoTo explain the flaw in the reasoning, it's easiest to generalize - y = x ^ (x ^ x ^ x ^ ...) = x ^ y and hence x = y ^ (1/y) = exp( 1/y * log(y) ) which is defined for y > 0. Graphing this using Google plot [0] or Wolfram Alpha [1], or just differentiating, reveals that it has a maximum at x = e, and that x takes the value sqrt(2) at both y = 2 and y = 4. Therefore the inversion, which is the original equation y = x ^ (x ^ x ^ x ^ ...) is dual-valued, i.e. it is not a mathematical function. For it to be a function, you need to specify whether you are on the upper branch (so that y = 4) or the lower branch (so that y = 2). Deliberately obfuscating the difference between the two branches leads to the conclusion that 2 = 4. The square root function can lead to a similar confusion, since there are two solutions to the equation y = x^2 and hence the "function" x = sqrt(y) is not really a function unless we specify whether we are on the upper (x > 0) or lower (x < 0) branch. By convention we interpret sqrt(y) to be the upper branch, and write -sqrt(y) for the lower branch, but there's nothing that forces that choice. Obfuscating the difference between the two branches could lead one to conclude that 1 = -1, although the fallacy is more obvious in this case, since everyone is familiar with the fact that the square root function is dual-valued. [0] https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=y%5E(1%2Fy) https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=y%5E(1%2Fy) [1] http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=y%5E(1%2Fy) http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=y%5E(1%2Fy)
- voicereasonish 13y agoAlso the big red flag in the reasoning is: > "But take the square root of each side". Sorry, but that's not really something you can do without recognising the fact that there are two square roots.
- j2kun 13y agoThis is a red herring.
- jds375 13y agoIt's certainly not a mathematical function. That being said, to even write 4 = x ^ (x ^ x ^ x ^ ...) is a bit misleading. The function diverges for y not in the range of e^-1 < y < e. I think that's a bit simpler and elegant way to look at it. A proof can be found on page 240: http://www.maa.org/sites/default/files/pdf/upload_library/22/Chauvenet/Knoebelchv.pdf http://www.maa.org/sites/default/files/pdf/upload_library/22... (pdf)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- j2kun 13y agoI think your argument is avoiding the real issues. One problem is that the simplification of setting y = x^y introduces new solutions that are not solutions to the original equation. While any solution of the original must also satisfy y = x^y, the reverse is not true. Even worse, the OP's algebraic manipulations assume there exists a solution to the equation. It's not logically sound to assume something exists and use that fact to prove that it exists.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pavpanchekha 13y agoWell... except that, if by equality you mean mathematical equality as real numbers, and by "0.9…" you mean the limit of the sequence (0.9, 0.99, 0.999, …), then in fact "0.9…" does equal 1. I'd argue that this is almost certainly what you in fact meant when you wrote "0.9", "1", and "equals". In fact, "0.9999… = 1" is true, and an appreciation of mathematics beyond a purely-syntactic level will make this clear. It will also help clear up puzzles like the OP.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ColinWright 13y agoThe comment to which this is a reply has been deleted. To give this comment (its siblings) context, there is the text: Yes I meant that. It makes no sense, because with that flawed logic you can formulate the following: 1/3 = 0.3... -> 0.3... * 3 = 0.9... -> 0.9.. = 3/3 = 1 If anything, 0.9... APPROACHES 1. Something like 0.9... ~ 1 is a better notation. Consider the expression 0.9999... It's easy to write syntactic nonsense, so it's not obvious that this has any meaning at all. However, if you are going to give that a meaning, then the most reasonable meaning to assign is that it's the limit of the sequence: 0.9, 0.99, 0.999, 0.9999, 0.99999, ... The limit is 1. The terms of the sequence approach 1, yes, but the limit does not approach anything because it doesn't move and it doesn't change. The limit is a value, and that value is 1. Your comment about 0.999... approaching 1 is genuinely wrong, and very, very misleading. It's even more wrong (whatever that means) to say that 0.9999... ~ 1. That's genuinely not a better notation. The interpretation of the meaning of the expression 0.9999... as given above does not allow that the expression 0.9999... should have any value other than 1.[0] [0] Assuming you're working in the standard reals, which form the Archimedean totally ordered complete infinite field. If you're in non-standard analysis then that's something completely different.
- 13y ago
- Kiro 13y ago> But the part in brackets is the same as the whole Can someone explain what this means?
- jds375 13y agoSo the logic goes, consider x^x^x^...=2. We have an infinite tower of x's. Now, suppose we group all but the first x as so: x^(x^x^x^..)=2. The number of x's in the parenthesis is still infinite (infinity minus 1 is still infinity). We already know by hypothesis that x^x^x^...=2. So we can substitute this in for the term in parenthesis since they are both an infinite tower of x's and get: x^2=2.
- vezzy-fnord 13y agoFor more pseudomathematics like this: http://www.crank.net/maths.html http://www.crank.net/maths.html
- bartkappenburg 13y agoJust as wrong as saying: 1) Inf - 2 = Inf 2) Inf - 4 = Inf Hence: 2 = 4 Alway be careful when doing operations on infinite numbers, sequences etc. These are the kind of things that roll out of that. The author just found a way to write something similar in a more fancier way.
- jds375 13y agoThe difference is that the equation is actually correct for y=2. It doesn't apply for y=4 because it only converges in the range e^-1 < y < e.
- Houshalter 13y agoEDIT: Ignore this. I tried doing this for x = sqrt(2) and it quickly approaches infinity. What is the actual solution for x?
- ColinWright 13y agoI don't see what you're doing to make it approach infinity. Let r0=sqrt(2) and r(i+1)=sqrt(2)^r(i). Then r0 = 1.4142135624 r1 = 1.6325269194 r2 = 1.7608395559 r3 = 1.8409108693 r4 = 1.8927126968 r5 = 1.9269997018 r6 = 1.9500347738 r7 = 1.9656648865 ... This is clearly approaching 2. Not sure what you were doing. Edit: Ah! I see - you've got the association the wrong way round. The convention is that a^b^c is a^(b^c). This is because (a^b)^c can just as easily be expressed as a^(bc), so you get more expressive power.
- Houshalter 13y agoYou're right. I just completely abused math and did previous^x rather than x^previous. Fixed the code and it does become 2. Thanks.
- belovedeagle 13y agoI don't believe all the comments pointing out that x^(x^...) converges only in a certain range are the best way to understand what's going on here. The way I see it, the "solve for x" puzzle really just serves to obscure the true reasoning used: if y=sqrt(2)^y and z=sqrt(2)^z, then y=z. When put like this, we can see that this is clearly false: solutions to the equation need not be equal any more than all zeros of a polynomial need be equal.
- j2kun 13y agoWell if you observe the tower power is an injective function then that just fixes everything :)
- cousin_it 13y agoSo to recap: 1) If we define f(x)=x^x^x^... as the limit of the sequence x, x^x, x^x^x, ... then f(sqrt(2))=2, not 4, and in fact there's no such x that f(x)=4. 2) If we instead "solve" the equation y=x^x^x... by dubious manipulations with infinite expressions, we get x=y^(1/y), so y=2 and y=4 both lead to x=sqrt(2). When playing with infinite expressions, you must always keep in mind how they're defined in terms of limits. If you learn to do that, many puzzles with infinity will stop bothering you forever, like Zeno's paradox, 0.999...=1, etc.
- aschwa32 13y agowhy did you write this?
- ColinWright 13y agoIt's a puzzle, and a good one. There are puzzles where the challenge is to work out what the insight is needed to see the solution, and there are puzzles where the challenge is to work out exactly what calculation is needed (and then to do it). In this case the puzzle is to find the error in the reasoning. Other examples of this include the two-envelope problem, the unexpected hanging, and the case of the missing dollar. Sometimes puzzles like this reveal deep insights into the subject, sometimes they point out that "obvious" things aren't obvious, and sometimes they reveal weaknesses in our understanding or reasoning. This is - for some students - an excellent introduction to why we need to be careful when dealing with certain types of mathematical manipulation.