6 ms·
Really, really sloppy benchmarking work here -- only four machines were tested, and every one of them had a drive from a different manufacturer. They weren't ev
by duskwuff 13y ago
Really, really sloppy benchmarking work here -- only four machines were tested, and every one of them had a drive from a different manufacturer. They weren't even all the same size! It's already well-known that Apple sources SSDs (as well as other parts) from a variety of suppliers, and not all of them perform identically. Concluding that the 2014 model is "slower" than the 2013 models from a sample this small is totally inappropriate, though.
- BorisMelnik 13y agoCompletely agree. I suppose the benchmark tests were a good start, but far from complete. To back up what you said here is a post from 2013 "not all Mac SSD's are the same" http://blog.macsales.com/19008-performance-testing-not-all-2013-macbook-air-ssds-are-the-same http://blog.macsales.com/19008-performance-testing-not-all-2...
- meisterbrendan 13y agoIs the variance between manufacturers really that dramatic? If so, as a future buyer, how can I make sure I get the fastest among the ostensibly identical SSDs for a given configuration?
- macspoofing 13y agoReturn policy
- Lagged2Death 13y ago>Concluding that the 2014 model is "slower" than the 2013 models from a sample this small is totally inappropriate, though. You only need one sample to make the point that it may be slower, and that's very much contrary to expectations.
- coldtea 13y agoHe already explained that the expectations are wrong to begin with. 2013 models had drives from different manufactures and some of those were slower than others. Here's an example: Say 2013-A-SSD > 2013-B-SSD and we have the same two A and B SSDs in 2014 machines. Then 2013-A-SSD > 2014-B-SSD. With just one machine (and without knowing the specifics) you can deduce from the above that "2014 drives are slower than 2013s" when in fact they are the exact same 2 models that 2013 Air's had.
- pdpi 13y agoWhich still means that, if you buy a 2014 model, you might get a machine that's slower than the 2013 model. It's not always the case, but it _can_ be -- which, as a prospective buyer, is infuriating.
- shabadoop 13y ago>Which still means that, if you buy a 2014 model, you might get a machine that's slower than the 2013 model. I think what you mean is "You might get a machine that's slower than _a_ 2014 model". Assuming every 2014 model performs at the baseline, unless that baseline is lower than the previous generation's you're still getting better performance than the _official_ 2013 model.
- nezza-_- 13y agoAnd which model is the "official" one if not the one that I bought in the Apple Store? There is no official and unofficial one, they're all sold under the same name. If I have a 2013 MBA I expect the SSD when I upgrade to a 2014 one to be at least as fast as the old one.
- coldtea 13y agoOK, let's put it this way: Apple doesn't guarrantee you a specific speed, and doesn't tell you you'll get a specific SSD model in your Air. It just tells you you'll get a speedy SSD of X capacity (true), and you're not supposed to obsess over manufacturer and a couple percentage points of performance. Else, you wouldn't have bought the Air, but some custom rig.
- toast0 13y agoWhat expectation? Apple tech specs are very brief for the ssd drives, just size and 'PCIe based', and they have a nebulous comparison to a spinning drive. They also don't tell you what model processor you get, just family and speed.
- Pacabel 13y agoThe expectation is that a 2014 model will perform at least as well, if not better than, a predecessor model from 2013. That's a perfectly reasonable expectation to hold, as well. One really shouldn't end up worse off (for whatever reason) merely by buying a more recent model, especially when it's a computer that's being purchased.
- yeukhon 13y ago> already well-known that Apple sources SSDs (as well as other parts) from a variety of suppliers Ah. Why would they do that? Someone could spend $3000 on MacBook Pro 16GB + SSD highest spec and risk the chance of getting bad parts? I never knew this was a practice. Is this even common in the industry otherwise Apple?
- wmf 13y agoApple would probably argue that all the SSDs provide acceptable performance and some of them provide bonus performance beyond what was promised. The specs only mention "PCIe-based flash storage": http://www.apple.com/macbook-air/specs.html http://www.apple.com/macbook-air/specs.html Apple has done this various times in the past, like shipping a 16x DVD drive when they advertised 8x. More problematic was the rMBP where LG LCDs were noticeably lower quality than Samsungs. http://9to5mac.com/2013/03/20/macbook-pro-with-retina-display-problems-in-every-dimension/ http://9to5mac.com/2013/03/20/macbook-pro-with-retina-displa...
- john2x 13y agoWow, that's unfortunate about the LG vs Samsung screens. How could you tell what screen you have? I'd like to spread awareness about this to my friends.
- sudhirj 13y agoThis was pretty easily fixed, though. The technician took one look at it, nodded, and I had it replaced for free while on Christmas + New Year vacation.
- john2x 13y agoMaybe in the US. But in the Philippines, we're out of luck. EDIT: I mean about the replacement part. Sure, they'll probably replace it after a several back and forth, plus the replacement will take serveral weeks.
- nimeshneema 13y ago
- xutopia 13y agoWhat you're saying is scary to me. Does this mean I could buy a Macbook Air and get a slower one than if you buy one?
- konstruktor 13y agoApple are sourcing parts from several component vendors, with varying performance, and name the resulting product exactly the same. They don't even specify what variants exist. How is somebody doing benchmarks supposed to test all possible configurations if they don't know how many exist, and have no way of determining which configuration they are buying?
- Holbein 13y agoExactly. You could argue that if Apple is happy with this situation where some of its customers get worse products than others, then this is absolutely worth punishing Apple for. And a good way to do this is by publishing benchmark reviews with bad values for the new thing.
- shabadoop 13y agoThey all meet a baseline standard, it's just some people get machines that are above those baselines. Yes, sometimes the "good" machine from a previous generation will outperform the baseline from the next generation in a given benchmark, but that's an inevitability of having machines that outperform the baselines of their generation.
- Pacabel 13y agoThis really depends on where you set the baseline standard. You may see the worst-performing variants of a given model as defining the baseline, with some being above the baseline. But it's perfectly legitimate to define the baseline at the best-performing variants of a given model, with some unfortunately being below the baseline. Personally, I prefer to set expectations high, and define the baseline based on the best that has been achieved so far. The worst-performing variant from 2014 should still be expected to exceed, or at the very worst be equal to, the best-performing variant from 2013.